Skip to main content
riccardod77850268
riccardod77850268
Participant
November 19, 2017
Answered

Lightroom CC and Lightroom Classic: I need more clarity, please

  • November 19, 2017
  • 2 replies
  • 230 views

Dear  all,

Thank you in advance to anyone who could help me to understand.

I've been looking in all the FAQs and discussions, but I could not solve this (apparently very simple) issue:

I have a very large catalogue on Lightroom, now Lightroom Classic. It works quite well, even if I always have been looking for a way for syncing all the pictures on the cloud.

Now, it seems that Lightroom CC could be perfect for this.

What I do not understand is how to make them work together properly. More precisely:

- Should I migrate the existing Catalogue I have in Classic into CC? (I have tried, by the way, but it seems to duplicate all the picture and my hard drive runs out of space...)

- If not, what exactly should I do?

Thank You very much

Riccardo

This topic has been closed for replies.
Correct answer Jao vdL

There are three major problems with trying to migrate a large catalogs. First is that you need enormous amounts of hard disk space to do it before everything is uploaded to the cloud even assuming you have the cloud space to do this! This is prohibitive for most people with large catalogs and is very hard to work around. Second is that Lightroom CC's features are extremely limited. Do not expect to be able to do even 10% of what you do in Classic. As Jim says  it seems to be targeted towards the iPhone shooter crowd with very limited needs. Third is that communication between Classic and CC is limited. Classic is smart enough to see that the images in the cloud are the same that it already has and will link the new cloud images to the ones it has but a lot of properties (keywords, etc.) do not sync. Also new imports into Classic do not end up in CC automatically. So you could become out of sync very quickly and have different things on both sides.

I am sure LR CC will get better and have more features. However Adobe has indicated the sync features in Classic will not be improved. This really means that if you now need anything that you can do in Classic say like actually printing, hierarchical keywords, publish services, etc. etc. you should stick with Classic and just play a bit with CC. The interesting thing is that you can simply sync collections from Classic and they will show up (albeit just smart previews) in CC and you can play with it that way.

2 replies

J
Community Expert
Jao vdLCommunity ExpertCorrect answer
Community Expert
November 19, 2017

There are three major problems with trying to migrate a large catalogs. First is that you need enormous amounts of hard disk space to do it before everything is uploaded to the cloud even assuming you have the cloud space to do this! This is prohibitive for most people with large catalogs and is very hard to work around. Second is that Lightroom CC's features are extremely limited. Do not expect to be able to do even 10% of what you do in Classic. As Jim says  it seems to be targeted towards the iPhone shooter crowd with very limited needs. Third is that communication between Classic and CC is limited. Classic is smart enough to see that the images in the cloud are the same that it already has and will link the new cloud images to the ones it has but a lot of properties (keywords, etc.) do not sync. Also new imports into Classic do not end up in CC automatically. So you could become out of sync very quickly and have different things on both sides.

I am sure LR CC will get better and have more features. However Adobe has indicated the sync features in Classic will not be improved. This really means that if you now need anything that you can do in Classic say like actually printing, hierarchical keywords, publish services, etc. etc. you should stick with Classic and just play a bit with CC. The interesting thing is that you can simply sync collections from Classic and they will show up (albeit just smart previews) in CC and you can play with it that way.

    JP Hess
    JP Hess
    Inspiring
    November 19, 2017

    The two programs aren't designed to work together.........yet. That's going to take some time for Adobe to really integrate them. The new Lightroom CC is for a different crowd right now. It seems to be for people who want to quickly download images and do a little editing and then share those images on social media. All of the tools are not in Lightroom CC. I find that the synchronization between the two programs isn't as complete and as smooth as I would want it to be. My suggestion would be for you to just experiment with it for a while and watch it grow and develop. Don't try to make it a serious part of your workflow right now.

    Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
    Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices