Skip to main content
Participant
Oct 6, 2026 8:46 PM UTC
Question

Lightroom Desktop 9.6 randomly changes or loses the crop/aspect ratio after switching images or exporting.

Application: Adobe Lightroom Desktop — not Lightroom Classic
Lightroom version: 9.6 x64 [20260923-1659-a32d844] (Sep 23 2026)
Internal Camera Raw version: 18.7 [2743]
Operating system: Windows 11 Pro, 64-bit
CPU: AMD Ryzen 5 7430U with Radeon Graphics
RAM: 32 GB
GPU: AMD Radeon (TM) Graphics
GPU driver / DirectX information: 31.0.12027.9001
Display: 2560 × 1440

Problem description:
Lightroom Desktop intermittently changes or loses a crop that I have already set on an image.

I manually set the crop and aspect ratio, continue editing the image, and everything appears correct.

After I either switch to another image or export the edited image, I sometimes return to the previously edited image and find that Lightroom has changed the crop/aspect ratio automatically.

For example, the image may unexpectedly appear with an aspect ratio such as 2:3 or 16:9, although I did not change or reset the crop.

The issue occurs with both Sony ARW files and JPEG files.

Important additional observation:
When the problem occurs, the previously selected crop/aspect ratio is also no longer present in the corresponding XMP data. This suggests that the issue is not only a visual display problem in Lightroom, but that the previously stored crop information itself is being lost or overwritten.

Once this has happened, I have not been able to restore the original crop using Ctrl+Z (Undo) or by using other troubleshooting methods and solutions suggested by Adobe Support.

Steps to reproduce:

  1. Open an ARW or JPEG image in Lightroom Desktop.
  2. Open the Crop tool.
  3. Set the desired crop and aspect ratio manually.
  4. Continue editing the image normally.
  5. Switch to another image or export the edited image.
  6. Continue working with other images.
  7. Return to the previously edited image.
  8. In some cases, the previously selected crop/composition has changed automatically.
  9. The original crop cannot be restored with Ctrl+Z, and the previously selected crop information is no longer present in the XMP data.

Expected result:
Once a crop has been set and confirmed, Lightroom should retain the selected crop and composition unless I manually change or reset it.

The crop information should also remain stored in the image metadata/XMP data and should not be removed or overwritten without user action.

Actual result:
Lightroom intermittently changes or removes the crop/aspect ratio of an already edited image without any action from me.

The previously selected crop cannot be recovered afterwards using Ctrl+Z or other troubleshooting methods.

The issue is intermittent and does not occur every single time, but it has occurred repeatedly during normal editing sessions.

I have already contacted Adobe Support via chat, but the issue could not be resolved.

Please investigate this as a possible Lightroom Desktop crop/aspect-ratio persistence or metadata bug, rather than as a question about how to use the Crop tool.

    11 replies

    Participant
    Nov 16, 2026 10:26 AM UTC

    Using Adobe lightroom 10.0 and this bug is still persistant! Adobe sort this annoying issue out its been months!!

    Translate
    nik.m
    Community Manager
    Community Manager
    Nov 16, 2026 3:24 PM UTC

    Hi, we're sorry that the issue persists.

    Please go to the Help menu in Lightroom, then System Info, and copy the text. You can share the info with us by either pasting it as a reply here or in a text file and sharing the file with us. 

    It would be helpful if you could share a short video of the behavior, as Claire requested.


    Thanks,
    Nikunj

    Translate
    Participant
    Oct 27, 2026 11:29 AM UTC

    Mac reproduction of the same issue, same build, with before/after sidecar files

    @^CH — you wrote that this could not be reproduced on Mac. Here it is on macOS, twice in one morning, with the original and the rewritten XMP files attached.

    Environment
    - Lightroom Desktop 9.6 x64 [20260923-1659-a32d844] (Sep 23 2026), Camera Raw 18.7 [2743], Creative Cloud build
    - macOS 26.6.2 (25G83), MacBook Pro M5 Pro, 48 GB RAM; GPU setting "Custom: display only"
    - Local mode (local folder on an external APFS SSD, not synced). Canon EOS R5 Mark II CR3 + XMP sidecars. Edits include Enhance (Denoise), AI masks, generative remove; some photos are "Flattened".
    - Nothing else touches these sidecars: no Bridge, no Lightroom Classic, no sync client.

    What happens
    Lightroom rewrites an XMP sidecar without any user edit to that photo. In both files the only develop change is crs:CropBottom set to "1" — the bottom edge of the crop jumps to the image edge. All other crop values, masks and settings are unchanged (unified diffs attached).

    Case 1 — IMG_2030 (Flattened, Upright on, generative expand at the bottom edge)
    - Sidecar written by Lightroom on 2026-10-26 18:19:22 with CropBottom="0.915448".
    - 2026-10-27 09:26: "Refresh folder" from the folder context menu, after Lightroom had purged its renders under memory pressure.
    - 09:28:10: Lightroom rewrites the sidecar: CropBottom="1", three CorrectionSyncID values regenerated, nothing else. In Develop the photo now shows a transparent strip at that edge.

    Case 2 — IMG_2089 (not Flattened: Enhance + AI masks, CropAngle −4.87, no Upright)
    - Sidecar from 2026-10-26 19:38:57 with CropBottom="0.757036".
    - 2026-10-27 ~11:13: a fresh Lightroom process opens the parent folder (1167 CR3). The user views three other photos. IMG_2089 is never opened.
    - 11:16:49: Lightroom rewrites IMG_2089.xmp: CropBottom="1", one CorrectionSyncID regenerated, nothing else.

    Checked
    - Of 6230 sidecars in the shoot only these two changed that day.
    - The catalog database and the library folder were not written at 09:28:10 or 11:16:49, so the value is produced in memory, not read from a store.
    - Both rewrites happened while Lightroom was in a long single-core phase (UI blocked 20–40 s per photo, one core at 100 %) that this machine shows on every first open of an Enhance/Flattened photo. I will file that separately with sampled stacks.
    - Case 1 happened on a factory configuration. During case 2 a config.lua with debug keys was present (memory-limit and thread-count flags only); it is not the cause, since case 1 happened without it.

    Attached: adobe_report_2026-10-27.zip — both before/after XMP pairs with diffs, three `sample` captures of the process, a Jetsam report, per-8-second process memory/CPU log around both events, app.log, Camera Raw log, system info. Full write-up in REPORT.md inside the zip.

    Expected: a sidecar must not be rewritten unless the user changed the photo, and the crop must never move on its own.

    Translate
    Claire H.
    Community Manager
    Community Manager
    Oct 6, 2026 9:12 PM UTC

    Hi ​@smooth_naturef59e, Thanks for reaching out and for the thorough bug report! I am unable to reproduce this on Mac, but we will continue to test on Windows. In the meantime, to help you with this issue, we would like a few more details. Can you send your system info and a screen recording of the issue? You can find your system info by going to Help > System Info, copying and pasting it into a text file, and attaching it here. Thanks! ^CH

    Translate
    Participant
    Oct 6, 2026 10:10 PM UTC

    Hi Claire,

    thank you for your reply and for continuing to investigate the issue on Windows.

    I will send you a screen recording of the issue as soon as possible. I have already tried to reproduce the bug intentionally, but unfortunately it did not occur “on demand” during my attempts.

    Since the issue appears intermittently, I will keep trying and will record it as soon as it happens again.

    Best regards,
    Christian

    Translate
    Claire H.
    Community Manager
    Community Manager
    Oct 7, 2026 10:19 PM UTC

    ​@smooth_naturef59e Thanks, Christian! We will keep an eye out for your system info and screen recording if it happens again. Wishing you easy and happy editing! ^CH

    Translate