Generative Fill in Photoshop Beta

Beta or not, I do not think the gen fill will ever have the ability to redraw a selected element, like a bear paw, to scale and attach it to the arm where the original paw was located. I have done many, many tests on that simple request, redrawing a somewhat realistic cartoon bear paws to decrease the paw (has no claws) from 4 fingers to 3. (I tried other similar tasks without success, but the bear paw is simple to explain.)

When you tell Mid Journey, Bing Image Generator  (Dal-E) and even this PS beta to draw something using prompts it does the request, on a blank page, but that is incredibly more simple then gen fill within a piece of art, although what Mid Journey, etc. does is mind blowing.

But Gen Fill is different! It will be impossible to fill a small area of a drawing accurately. It only reads the pixels around it and doesn't have human eyes and brain to understand what it is seeing. Other full drawings like discussed above does NOT need to see and understand what the pixels around the area means. Like, "Oh, this is a bears arm. I need to add the new paw right here. and I have to get the scale right."  So I got so many weird things in a small area where I was trying to (auto fiill) redraw one paw. I tried many, many prompts and auto fill. Absolutely nothing came even remotely close to the original paw. The original paw did not have claws, but the gen fill gave weird claws including one with candles as claws. One fill gave white, mickey mouse gloves. And nothing came close to attaching a revised paw to the arm. The new fill showed new crazy paws (all sizes) pointing everywhere. Worse is that there is no way it can understand how to create at the proper scale. Maybe creating a bear claw through commands on a blank page then resizing it and rotating it and blending to the arm would work after a lot of work, but that it not gen fill. 

Does it work with an older Intel Mac? I tried installing it on my work machine, a 2019 MBP but it just gave me the beach ball when I launched it. Could be that VPN thing, I suppose, but I need IT to turn it off, and they won't let me use the machine without it (working from home). That said, I did also install the beta on my personal machine that's a newer MBP with M1 and it worked like a charm! I hear what people are saying about accuracy, etc., but for my purposes, comping labels that have photogrpahy, I'm mostly using stock already and either compositing a composition for the photoshoot, or extending surfaces and that kind of thing. Saved me a TON of time. Really looking forward to the release version, where I'm sure the resolution issues and other things will be more buttoned up.

Thanks. I'm looking forward to trying it. Wondering if it's available on photoshop for iPad as I've just bought a new iPad Pro?

Is there a way to fix the tecture of the generated image? all results doesn't reflect the orginal photo image. example below:

Generated part on the left.

Great start adobe with the generative tool! Just used it for the first time and I'm wondering if in the future you could select your own content to be merged with the background image. Say I already had a mouse juggling cheese rolls on one layer and I wanted it to embed into the scene matching lighting, perspective etc, it would be awesome to drag the subject layer into the Generate text box and let it do its thing. 

Hi, I recently use generative fill but it is always loading with the green panel, nothing show up, anyone experience?

Hello, my previous message dissappeared, does anyone have the problem that beta is installed in creative cloud it activates the open button but does not open, it is not present in the launchpad. All updates installed on both Creative Cloud and MacOS 13.1.

Thanks

My Generative fill AI is currnetly unavailable, any help?

This is really cool, but it does a bad job on people's faces, and warping arms and legs in weird unnatural ways.