Skip to main content
Participant
January 20, 2025
Question

Adobe Generative Fill is a terrible beta product

  • January 20, 2025
  • 3 replies
  • 468 views

it's jan 20th, 2025 and working with generative fill is a terrible option.

The workarounds suggested by adobe team itself are unpresentable and unprofessional.

I need a fix now! I'm using Photoshop V26.2.0

 

Been trying to expand a basic ocean surface for a picture and it keeps giving plain no textured images or waves that looks like carpets and has nothing to do with the raw image wavy surface... your tool can't detect and create water surface??? pff, it can't even detect the waves direction to copy them, at bests it gives me wavy water that doesn't correlate with the rest of the water surface >.< [removed by moderator]

 

This has been advertised as the most advanced artificial intelligence tool and is far from being usable.

I don't care if i need to use 1080x1080 squares or a camera raw workaround, it should work as advertised IN the APP!

This is [removed] close to a mass fraud. 

Midjourney and runway with stable diffusion does far better work w fine details. Even taking screenshots with runway and enhancing 'em with Topaz works better than this [removed by moderator]. I'm taking it to linkedin.

 

[removed], I hope y'all get fired.

 

3 replies

pixxxelschubser
Community Expert
Community Expert
January 21, 2025

based on your screenshot it gives me:

or

 

Stephen Marsh
Community Expert
Community Expert
January 21, 2025

@BlackFox LTDA 

 

Have you tried using Generative Expand via the Crop tool (without or with a prompt), or Content Aware Fill?

creative explorer
Community Expert
Community Expert
January 20, 2025

@BlackFox LTDA I am on the opposite of that. I don't mind Generative Fill. It really does come down and writing exactly what you want, and telling the 'prompt' the correct description. There are many different ways to say something. And you need to figure out that 'sweet spot!' 

m