Participant

Answered

Photoshop 27.10 forces “Save As” when pressing Ctrl+S on an existing JPEG

8 replies
127 views
Translate

Photoshop version:
27.10

OS:
Windows 11

Issue:
After updating Photoshop, pressing Ctrl+S or choosing File > Save on an already existing JPEG no longer saves directly back to the original JPEG file. Instead, Photoshop opens the Save As dialog.

This did not happen in my previous workflow and significantly interrupts a high-volume production process.

Steps to reproduce:
1. Open an existing .jpg file in Photoshop.
2. Make a normal image edit.
3. Press Ctrl+S or choose File > Save.
4. Photoshop opens the Save As dialog instead of saving directly back to the existing JPEG.

Expected result:
Ctrl+S / File > Save should save directly back to the currently opened JPEG file, as it did previously.

Actual result:
Photoshop opens the Save As dialog and requires additional interaction with the filename and/or file format.

Additional information:
- JPEG is enabled under Customize Save Dialog File Formats.
- “Open JPEG without Background layer” is disabled.
- “Enable legacy Save As” is enabled.
- I am deliberately using Save, not Save As.
- The same issue still occurs after downgrading from Photoshop 27.10 to 27.7.
- Manually flattening the image is not an acceptable workaround because this extra step was not required in my previous workflow.

Impact:
This behavior adds unnecessary repetitive steps to every JPEG save operation and significantly reduces production efficiency in a high-volume workflow.

Request:
Please restore the previous Ctrl+S / File > Save behavior for existing JPEG files, or provide a preference that allows users to disable this behavior.

JohanElzengaCorrect answer

Community Expert

Check that your ‘normal edit’ does not create a layer without you realizing that. There are several tools that can be set to create a new layer with their edits, and also the crop tool can do the same (if you uncheck the ‘delete cropped pixels’ checkbox).

-- Johan W. Elzenga

c.pfaffenbichler

Community Expert

@motivated_Panther0636 , please clarify your »normal image edits« and, as per @Stephen Marsh ’s remark, where the jpg/s in question originated.

Translate

Stephen Marsh

Community Expert

Another case is where the JPEG was created by another non Adobe application and Photoshop has to write its own native compression into the file.

Translate

jane-e

Community Expert

@motivated_Panther0636 wrote: “2. Make a normal image edit.”

Please tell us exactly what the “normal image edit” was so we can test with the same edit.

Jane

Translate

Trevor.Dennis

Community Expert

Your image has:

More than one layer

Has content outside the canvas bounds (cropped with Delete cropped pixels unchecked.

Has an alpha channel (saved selection)

Note(s)

Color sampler point(s)

Rule

more than 8 bit.

You actually can save to JPG with an active workpath.

Make an Action that ‘flattens’ layers, sets to 8 bit, and does File Save and trigger it with a Function key (F2 for instance)

When an image plays up, hit F2 and you are done.

Translate

D Fosse

Community Expert

@motivated_Panther0636

What you need to be aware of is that the jpeg file format specification does not support layers of any kind (as pointed out by Johan), 16 bit depth, transparency or alpha channels.

Most people don’t realize how limited the jpeg format is, and most “normal” edits in Photoshop will put the document outside the jpeg specification.

The standard way to deal with this is to make an action that flattens/converts to 8 bit/removes alpha channels, and assign an F-key to it. That’s a single keystroke, and you’re good to go, especially if you also include the save to jpeg in the action.

Translate

JohanElzenga

Correct answer

Community Expert

Check that your ‘normal edit’ does not create a layer without you realizing that. There are several tools that can be set to create a new layer with their edits, and also the crop tool can do the same (if you uncheck the ‘delete cropped pixels’ checkbox).

Translate

-- Johan W. Elzenga

c.pfaffenbichler

Community Expert

I cannot reproduce the problem (not that I would consider re-saving a jpg and thus increasing the compression-damage advisable) but what exactly do you mean by

2. Make a normal image edit.

?

Could you please post screenshots including all pertinent Panels?

Translate

Ged_Traynor

Community Expert

@motivated_Panther0636 I cannot replicate the issue with Photoshop version 27.10 on Windows 11, have you tried resetting the Photoshop preferences

Translate

Sign up

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Sign in to Adobe Community

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.