Skip to main content
Participant
Sep 10, 2025 7:41 PM UTC
Question

Remove tool always creates new layer regardless of setting

When using the remove tool in 26.10.0, if the box "Create new layer" is unchecked, it still creates a "Remove tool edits" layer.

3 replies

Mike_Harvey
Participant
Nov 21, 2026 3:25 PM UTC

I have this exact same issue on a PC.  Irritating as I always work on a copy of the original layer, converted to a smart object. The new layer is not a smart object.  Easy enough to merge them both into a smart object, but a lot of extra work if doing a lot of editing.

Translate
D Fosse
Community Expert
Community Expert
Nov 21, 2026 8:25 PM UTC

​@Mike_Harvey 

There’s a good reason for this. Smart objects cannot be edited on a direct pixel level. Hence the added layer containing the edit.

In the old days you’d just get a message that it’s a forbidden operation.

Translate
Community Manager
Sep 10, 2025 8:40 PM UTC

Hi @ethereal_reporter7645, welcome to the community!

I tried testing this on my end but couldn’t reproduce the issue. Could you try resetting your Photoshop preferences? That can often help clear up odd glitches.

If that doesn’t do the trick, would you mind sharing a screenshot of Photoshop showing the full Layers panel and your Remove Tool settings? That’ll help us take a closer look.

Thanks so much!
Alek

Translate
*(If you mention me with an @, like @Aleke, I’ll get a notification and can respond faster.)*