Skip to main content
Participant
November 26, 2018
Question

Saving CMYK image while preserving colors

  • November 26, 2018
  • 4 replies
  • 4847 views

Hey, I am relatively new to Photoshop and have learned the hard way about color profiles (without learning so much, haha). I have a bunch of files I've made in CMYK (Web Coated SWOP v2) because my main purpose was to print them on an inkjet I have. I figured starting in CMYK would mean getting more accurate colors when printing. I am now trying to save these files as images to share with others online but am having some issues. Whenever I save as a jpeg or use the Save As for Web and save as png-24, the colors are way more saturated and aren't accurate to what's displayed in Photoshop. I've tried converting to RGB but that also saturates the colors. The one way I can get the colors to display properly is by saving as a PDF but that's not necessarily ideal. Can anyone guide me on other ways to save files as images while preserving the colors to appear as they do in Photoshop?

This topic has been closed for replies.

4 replies

Z0rLordAuthor
Participant
November 27, 2018

So obviously I have learned, way after creating and working on a ton of files, that sRGB is the way to go. Is there any simple way to salvage these older files besides just saving as a PDF? I'm happy with the prints I got out of PS but sharing them, I'm worried the quality will be worse as PDF or the file size will be larger.

I actually started my first file in RGB but had Working CMYK proofing on for some reason (my first attempt using PS) so that made me research a bit after realizing all my colors were off. Just simply assumed sRGB was the monitor/web profile and CMYK was more accurate for printing since my inkjet has those cartridges. Thankfully doing this as a hobby, haha

Thanks for all the help and answers so far, really appreciate it

D Fosse
Community Expert
Community Expert
November 26, 2018

CMYK is for offset presses. Inkjet printers expect RGB.

Very few, if any, image viewers or web applications have any CMYK support at all! When fed CMYK data, they simply don't know what to do with it.

Use sRGB IEC61966-2.1 everywhere until you get more experience. That's safe and reproduces correctly in almost any situation.

Daniel E Lane
Inspiring
November 26, 2018

Your best bet is to always work and save in RGB, then to save off a separate file as your CMYK if you really need one. Some file types do not work as CMYK and others do not interpret that color scheme correctly. So RGB or sRGB are the main thing to work in. and CMYK only for printing.

And as to you printing on an inkjet you have, is it a large format professional inkjet, or just a normal one used for an office or something that can print some photos? If it's the small office type, don't send it a CMYK image, you won't like what it does. Those printers expect to receive an RGB image and have software built in to interpret the RGB into its own way of doing CMYK. If you send it a CMYK file, its going to interpret it as if it is an RGB image anyway and totally mess with your colors. Effectively give your a double CMYK process to the image, muting out a lot of your colors and making it look rather "off".

JonathanArias
Legend
November 26, 2018

You should stay in RBG for your image mode in photoshop, from photoshop you save a .tiff for print files, and do file save for web for your web graphics.