Any drive is Mac-compatible as long as you can format it with Apple Disk Utility. Just format it as APFS or Mac OS Extended and you’re good.
Reliability is difficult to predict because it’s a combination of the quality of the drive itself (brand and model), and the enclosure that the drive is inside (controller board, port, cable…).
The practical answer to the reliability question is:
- Always assume any type of drive can fail at any time, because that is true.
- To guard against that, always maintain at least one (preferably more than one) up-to-date backup of any drive containing data you consider irreplaceable.
The nice thing about a drive used only as a scratch disk is that the data is totally expendable, so you just need one, and you don’t have to back it up. It doesn’t have to be the most reliable because it’s only storing temporary files that are deleted the moment you exit Photoshop.
When people post on the Internet about their drive failing, it’s highly anecdotal…a drive of any brand/model will fail somewhere, we just never know whose. The others will continue working just fine for years. If you must have a quality ranking, a good source would be the reports by Backblaze because they manage thousands of drives for their cloud backup data centers. But, the drives they use for data centers might not be the size and type we would normally plug into our computer.
One very important last thing: You asked about a
100GB external HD
That’s not what you’re shopping for, for several reasons:
- 100GB is not that much, so if the point is to accommodate larger Photoshop files, aim for 500GB or more although 200+GB might work for most files.
- 100GB is no longer a common size for an external drive anyway, most trusted brands start at 256GB now.
- You don’t want an HD/HDD (hard drive/hard disk drive) today for a scratch disk, you want an SSD (solid state drive). The point of a scratch disk is to help RAM, the fastest kind of memory, and the high speeds of SSDs are much closer to RAM speed than hard drives are. We only used hard drives as scratch disks in the past because that’s all we had. But now that fast SSDs have become common and affordable, they are really the only practical choice for an external Photoshop scratch disk.
So look for an external SSD of 512GB or more. It should support a USB-C transfer speed of at least 10 gigabits (Gb)/second, which is roughly 1000 megabytes (MB) a second. Some examples would be the Samsung T series, Crucial X series, and SSDs by Sandisk or Glyph. All of those are commonly used by creative professionals.