Skip to main content
Known Participant
May 15, 2017
Answered

What is the difference between a new album or a new key tag for grouping? Please

  • May 15, 2017
  • 2 replies
  • 1296 views

Hi, thanks if advance:  If I want to group or quickly identify a batch of photos: "Johns First Birthday" for example: What is the difference if I set up a new Album: "Johns First Birthday" or an Event Key Tag: "Johns First Birthday". Thanks Ed.

    This topic has been closed for replies.
    Correct answer MichelBParis

    In simple words:

    - tags (or keywords, that's the same) are text properties you assign to a given media file. Generally, you assign several keywords to a given picture file for easy retrieval by combining the keywords. You can assign the same keyword to a number of selected files at the same time. The keywords are managed in the catalog (the database) and you can also 'write metadata to files' so that they can be seen from any other softwares without the catalog.

    - albums are not properties of a given file, they are simple lists like playlists  for audio files. They are only kept in the catalog and are a way to group files for a given purpose. They are NOT like folders. You can include a photo in several different 'albums' for different purposes, there is no duplication of the file itself; the photo included in several lists is the same. If you change it from the selection of one album the changes are seen from any other album.

    In practice: you should work mainly with keywords and create albums for a given purpose: showing, printing, sharing. Most users create many temporary albums for their current purpose and deleted those lists afterwards. The big advantage of those lists is that you can sort the list in your own custom order 'album order'.

    The advantage of keywords is that you can write them to file if you want to share them with other softwares (or different catalogs). It may be an additional safety beside backups.

    2 replies

    MichelBParis
    MichelBParisCorrect answer
    Legend
    May 15, 2017

    In simple words:

    - tags (or keywords, that's the same) are text properties you assign to a given media file. Generally, you assign several keywords to a given picture file for easy retrieval by combining the keywords. You can assign the same keyword to a number of selected files at the same time. The keywords are managed in the catalog (the database) and you can also 'write metadata to files' so that they can be seen from any other softwares without the catalog.

    - albums are not properties of a given file, they are simple lists like playlists  for audio files. They are only kept in the catalog and are a way to group files for a given purpose. They are NOT like folders. You can include a photo in several different 'albums' for different purposes, there is no duplication of the file itself; the photo included in several lists is the same. If you change it from the selection of one album the changes are seen from any other album.

    In practice: you should work mainly with keywords and create albums for a given purpose: showing, printing, sharing. Most users create many temporary albums for their current purpose and deleted those lists afterwards. The big advantage of those lists is that you can sort the list in your own custom order 'album order'.

    The advantage of keywords is that you can write them to file if you want to share them with other softwares (or different catalogs). It may be an additional safety beside backups.

    Dhananjay Sati
    Community Manager
    Community Manager
    May 15, 2017

    Hi ear,

    Thanks for posting in Adobe forums.

    Please read & follow this & this article for reference .

    Thanks

    Regards

    Dhananjay

    ear41Author
    Known Participant
    May 15, 2017

    Thanks Dhananjay I don't mean to be difficult but I do understand what an

    album and tag can do.

    So which is better or what is the difference if as my question stated, I

    wanted so name a bunch of photos "Johns First Birthday" and reference it

    quickly in PSE 15. Wouldn't an album named "Johns First Birthday" or a

    Event Keyword Tag labeled "Johns First Birthday" accomplish the same thing?

    Thanks

    On Mon, May 15, 2017 at 1:35 PM, dhananjays36801738 <

    MichelBParis
    Legend
    May 15, 2017

    ear41  wrote

    Thanks Dhananjay  I don't mean to be difficult but I do understand what an

    album and tag can do.

    So which is better or what is the difference if as my question stated, I

    wanted so name a bunch of photos "Johns First Birthday" and reference it

    quickly in PSE 15.  Wouldn't an album named "Johns First Birthday" or a

    Event Keyword Tag labeled "Johns First Birthday" accomplish the same thing?

    Thanks

    On Mon, May 15, 2017 at 1:35 PM, dhananjays36801738 <

    If you use the tag (keyword) 'Johns First Birthday' you can search from the different search options, particularly the new enhanced text search of PSE15 and you'll find your images immediately (no difference if it's an event category or any other category of your choice).

    If you want to search an album, you'll have to search for albums of that name in the folders panel on the left, or in the menu 'Find by detail' or in the 'advanced search' by selecting the album search type on the left.

    Which is better is your choice. I prefer using tags/keywords for searching in my big library, and I create albums for other purposes; sometimes temporarily for creating book pages for instance.