Baseball Scoreboard

If you want to automate the process with Automation Blocks, you would first need to create a Motion Graphics Template (mogrt) in After Effects and the use one of the workflows described here:
https://docs.mamoworld.com/automation-blocks/tools-pr/templateTools

​@mbvt,

I worked on the options years ago when my son was in little league. The options suggested by ​@Peru Bob and ​@John T Smith work. The downside is that you have to edit for every game/highlight event/change. If you only have a few, it is no big deal. 

But when you have many options, a “data-driven” option makes it simpler. Your enter your events in a spreadsheet (many or only a few) with timecode if you wish, and use it to fill in the graphic. See the 3 links in my post here:

Recently, I’ve been working more with the Automation Blocks plugin, and I am amazed at what it can do. ​@Mathias Moehl, has this already been done?

Stan

Try Illustrator or Photoshop.