Desaturated colors in timeline, Premiere Pro

When I import two files into my timeline, they appear different in color, even though they are supposed to be identical except for the position of the eyes. It shows up in bin, it shows up in timeline, it also appears after having rendered it out. Not the best at problem solving, so have just restarted computer and program. Don't really know what else to do. 

*EDIT:
It seems like the issue is only on the edited versions of the original image. They still appear the same in color viewing them in windows image viewer though, so I don't really see why it shows up different in Premiere.