Skip to main content
Known Participant
Nov 21, 2026 5:11 PM UTC
Question

POLL - DO YOU FEEL ADOBE ACTUALLY LISTENS TO USERS?

I’ve used Adobe Premiere for donkeys years and - like all of us - have put up with the bugs, the random updates where things change that don’t need changing, and other things that do need changing never get any attention. I’ve put up with the constant pushing of Gen AI (and the associated cost which has been passed on to users via increased subs costs) despite Firefly being awful and unnecessary compared to other products.

I genuinely wonder why Adobe does what it does, and how it arrives at the decision to do these things, despite all the user interaction on these boards, which seems to be ignored for the huge part. I’m looking at you, new Color Mode.

 

Anybody else here feel like that?

 

    1 reply

    R Neil Haugen
    Legend
    Nov 21, 2026 7:06 PM UTC

    First, as a long time user and troubleshooter by nature, I really wish a far higer percentage of the user base both read and posted on this forum daily. More detailed listings of bugs and performance issues would be most helpful, as would more posts about workflow issues and ideas.

    Ok … yea, I’m happy to upvote things that others post about even if I would probably never use it. Simply because I like have more user options period.

    And after that’s clear, as a long-time user (and one specialized in color actually), and someone who’s attended NAB for like 14 years now … many MAX conferences also … I’ve had a ton of interactions with both other users and with a wide array of staffers.

     

    Like any software company, they have 1) an internal group of fairly experienced people studying changes in the biz they make software for and therefore recommendaations and 2) a ton of comments across many different means, forums, socials, direct emails, and a lot of surveying of users, 3) in Adobe’s case, they also have their “Hollywood” group that builds mods for Hollywood level productions, much of which get incorporated into later builds, and 4) a decision making process that prioritizes things based on 1 and 2 and 3 above, and the expected costs for any changes.

    They also take into account that every part of the code needs rebuilding every 4-5 years, so they cycle througth the app one section at a time rebuilding code, and use that as the basis for major changes to move the app forward.

    The end result is that they do not listen to specific groups of users. If anything the “Hollywood” group gets more attention. But the user base of several million daily users is bluntly very scattered in what they work and and how they work.

    At NAB, one of my fav things is the amazing aisle-way discussions with other folks in the video post biz. No two people even in the same shop do the same thing the same way. No matter whether it’s Premiere, Resolve, AE, Nuke, whatever … everyone does everything differently than anyone else.

    So I learned to never assume anyone will ever work just like me. Or even want the same tools behaving the same way, as for another, what I want is anathema. And vice versa naturally.

     

    So I’ve seen posts to the effect of the following:

    “We don’t want NO AI, no one has ever asked for it in Premiere!”

     

    Well … actually, yes, a ton of users want some of the machine learning things. Captions, organizing bins, shot-matching color, all kinds of things. And those features are heavily used. So you can’t be seriuos with a comment of no one wanting any AI. It’s so factually blown out in practice.

    Personally, I’ve wanted a ton of changes in color ever since they dumped SpeedGrade (an actual grading app!) and stuck us with Lumetri. Now, few can push Lumetri farther than me, but not because I liked Lumetri, but because I need to do more than it was really designed to do. And yea, I could do multiple instances on a clip, multiple stacked track-matte sets to do complicated secondary work, at times having up to 15 tracks just to do color.

    But when I’d ask about all that at NAB, what I’d be told by devs was 1) they’d love to have all the advanced stuff I wanted for their own work, because every dev I’ve ever talked with does extensive personal video work for the fun of it … and 2) that what I wanted would actually get used by maybe 100 other users out of several million, so … take a guess how much budgeted time it’s gonna get … right.

    I’ve argued for other things at times also. Some of which got fixed after a couple cycles, some strangely to me, not.

    But then I also work daily in Resolve, and due to working for/with/teaching pro colorists, I’m also on the BM forums daily.

    Know something? Every colorist I know has a long list of the things they see wrong with Resolve … both bugs and general designed behaviors … that they’ve wanted changed forever and occasionally in a new release, one or two get changed. But of course, the new release has things they disagree with, so their lists stay about the same.

     

    Funally … as someone with a lot of experience in color mode being one of the first in the private beta … 1) at first it is totally bizarre and gosh-awful … a hot stinky mess. Yup!

    but 2) after you learn why Alexis came up with this, what it is designed to do, how the workflow has been re-thought about … and learn how to handle the new and odd toolset … it’s a truly amazing creation.

    It is the first system built from the ground-up for the way colorsits have been trying to work for the last five years or so, moving away from the hard painful slog of clip-to-clip shot-matching wherever, whenever, and however possible. So by intent an design the UI layout and tools are not like unto anything any of us have ever used before.

    It is disorienting, confusing, and totally opaque until you learn how it works. And adopt that different pattern of doing color.

    Then … it becomes fast and powerful to get through a sequence  with very little shot-matching involved.

    At NAB, I was in the booth when a few of the top named Hollywood colorists were working in this with staffers. They were very impressed with it. Which is wny it took the award as the hottest new product of NAB. For a reason.

    But again, at first … it’s … just dumbfounding.

    Translate
    Everyone's mileage always varies ...