Render In To Out Playback Issue

Premiere 23.2.0
Apple M1Pro 16-inch Macbook Pro

In Premiere 2022, I mapped "Render In to Out" to my keyboard (SHIFT + RETURN) and after rendering playback would start at my In Point and play until Out Point.

Now it starts at the beginning of my timeline and I cannot fix it.

"Play after rendering previews" is enabled in my Timeline Settings.

Any help or advice?