trying to find a graphic

So I made some lower 3rds a couple years ago, that always showed up in Graphic Templates/my templates on Premiere. I used them several times in other projects. 

However, my hard drive crashed a couple weeks ago and I had to replace. I still have access to the files on the old drive, so I’ve been slowly copying files over that I need. 

However, I cannot find those the lower 3rds I’ve been using. I’ve went through AppData (Yes, it’s a Windows machine), and all the folders suggested to try did not have anything. 

What are some  other places I can look? Or am I out of luck and do I have to re-create these graphics again?