Skip to main content
joew71899760
Inspiring
May 6, 2017
Question

Why did I get red flashes - single frames of red - in a Media Encoder output?

  • May 6, 2017
  • 2 replies
  • 2239 views

Hi everyone,

I have found that, at least from projects with enough effects in them, that outputting from Premiere to H.264 has been pretty treacherous.  Especially when I'm on a deadline, I'm looking for ways to reduce risk.

I recently took the following approach:  I output all 3 of my timelines for a project to Quicktime ProRes 422. All three ProRes movies came out clean and flawless.

Then I dropped those 3 separate Quicktime ProRes movies into a Media Encoder Queue to encode to H.264.  Generally, I'd hope that by baking my projects into a single Quicktime movie, I can sidestep many pitfalls (memory issues, troublesome effects, etc.)

Two of my 3 ProRes movies encoded just fine, producing clean H.264s for internet posting.  However, the third movie rendered out with two red flashes, single frames of red, which are NOT present in the ProRes originals (I double-checked.)

The 3 movies are very similar in length, content, etc. because they are 3 versions of the same program.

Again, looking back on the same frames on the original ProRes movie, there is no flash or glitch, nor anything else out of the ordinary.  So 2:29:06 in the H.264 is a frame of red, going back to 2:29:06 on the original - no red flash, nothing.

I rendered them all together, in the same queue.  I was in a hurry.  We video editors often are.  I am not able to find a record of what order the movies encoded in - was the one that came out with red flashes first, second or third?

So I'm very puzzled by why this would happen in the first place, and even so, why selectively?

My setup:  Late 2013 MacPro, 64 GB RAM, Mac OS 10.11.6, CC 2017.0.2 release (not the most current one.)  Media Encoder 11.02.53.

Thoughts?

This topic has been closed for replies.

2 replies

Participant
February 2, 2019

I was having a very similar issue and nothing worked. I finally checked and my raw footage was shot at a strange frame rate. I converted it using ADV Videoshare converter and seems to have solved the problem for me.

R Neil Haugen
Legend
May 6, 2017

I can't give an answer ... but I know there are a few things that for some reason can lead to ... or perhaps allow? ... glitches to occur in ME.  The first is the option "Import Sequences Natively" ... in the Edit/Preferences/General tab. The second is the 'Enable accelerated H.264 encoding" in the Media tab.

Back in PrPro, occasionally "Render with Maximum Quality" and "Maximum bit depth" can cause issues.

So ... changing one of those may help this ... maybe ... but at least, something to try.

One frame ... one frame only, please ...

Wow, that's a fun one to chase down!

Neil

Everyone's mileage always varies ...
joew71899760
Inspiring
May 7, 2017

I can vouch for the problems caused by "Import Sequences Natively" option in Media Encoder.  A tech from Adobe suggested I disable that feature, and things improved greatly.

I don't see "Enable accelerated H.264 Encoding" in the Media tab... perhaps once I update to the newest version?

But I wonder if the ME/Pref/General/Enable Parallel Encoding could cause problems.  I currently have it enabled.

Joe

R Neil Haugen
Legend
May 7, 2017

If you have an earlier version of PrPro, say 2015, then I think that's in the "General" tab, as it moved to the Media tab I recall in 2017. There's also the H.264 acceleration option in the MediaEncoder Media tab.

As to the "parallel encoding" ... I don't know. Maybe try changing it if the problem persists ...

Neil

Everyone's mileage always varies ...