Adobe Firefly refuses to remove an earring from a nose. Goes against the guidelines

[floramc]

Hi there, this was a first, and I took a screenshot of my screen. Mind that the picture is enlarged quite a bit.

I was working on a demonstration that I have to propose in two weeks, and I was trying to differentiate in generative fill between insert and remove.

I thought removing a nosering can be a good way to explain what removing parts of the image means. But my firefly refuses to do it.

At first I thought I made a too big selection, so I tried again as you see below, which is nothing but the size of the ring, and still I get the same answer.

[J E L]

Hi @floramc, yes, I had a similar experience with a test just now. Firefly was able to replace the nose ring with a different style using Insert > Add > Generate. But after keeping that version, I couldn't remove the new ring either. I tried a few other ways to go about it, but for some reason, it gives the violation error. Note, the action worked perfectly using the Remove Tool in Photoshop 25.0 Release. 

[floramc]

thanks. Apologize for mixing up earring and nose ring. I am in bed with a flu and my English degrades rapidly when I am under the weather. Will edit in a sec

I see your point, but then I definitely need to change picture, as this is supposed to work for a conference where I show the difference between insert and remove. Then I need to find someting else. Thanks again for your imput!

[J E L]

Ah, I hope you feel better soon. Technically, an earring could be fashioned into a nose ring, lol. In any event, Remove should work on this in Firefly because it does in Photoshop. I thought they were more closely aligned. I tried Firefly to remove a necklace, but that didn't work, either. Maybe it's too much skin in our test close-ups? But good luck with your demo—whatever you end up using!

[floramc]

Hi back!

I see your point and I tried zooming out and panning differently. So far, no luck. What surprises me is that it says that the request violates the guidelines. I don't see how.