Import 3D fbx animation isn't always there

I'm using AE 2025

We did the testing and got the texture and animation to appear with FBX files.

But when I bring new 3D models or have the working model brought into a new comp, the animation drop-down in the Animation Options is gone. 

I'm a bit clueless if it's a bug, a setting in the comps, or something specific I need to do beforehand. It's getting frustrating that the animation options exist in one comp and not in others. 

We did update the 3D Object's texture, but I feel like that shouldn't have caused any issues on the animation side