Project crashes on opening
I have a project that crashes After Effects every time I try to open it, with this error message:

I created the project in November 2022 in After Effects 22.3 on a 2019 MacBook Pro running macOS Big Sur 11.7. In late November I received a new computer for work - a brand new M1 Max 16" MacBook Pro - and since then, I've been unable to open the project.
This project uses a preset called Numbers+ by Creative Dojo, which, in the developer’s words “is just a bunch of expressions tied to a pseudo effect”. Since I migrated to a brand new M1 Max MacBook Pro, I haven’t been able to open the project, as it crashed with this same error message every time.
Here are a bunch of things I’ve tried, with no success:
- Download and reinstall the preset
- Remove the preset
- Reset After Effects cache
- Reset After Effects preferences
- Downgrade to the same version (22.3) of After Effects I used when creating the project
- Try every version since (22.4, 22.5, 22.6, 23.0)
- Reinstall after using Adobe’s Cleaner tool
- Create a new project, and import the original into the new project
My colleague is able to open this project, working on a Mac with identical configuration to mine (he received a new computer at the same time as I did).
It’s only on my computer that I can’t open it. My After Effects installation is ‘vanilla’ as it gets. I have no external scripts or plugins installed other than Numbers+.
My old computer, the one I used to create the project, was similar. It was also a vanilla AE setup, with just Numbers+, as well as Lottie and Bodymoving for Lottie exports. No other 3rd party tools.
If I use the Numbers+ preset in a different project (create a layer with the preset, adjust settings, etc.), I can save the project, and it’ll open just fine.
Even on a clean installation of After Effects without Numbers+, it still opens without trouble.
So as far as I can tell, there shouldn’t be any problem caused by this preset, just that AE always gets stuck opening this particular project on this particular computer.
Has anyone here come across a similar problem? This is driving me mad.
