Rendered Colors Do Not Match Composition Preview

I've been trying to render out a series of shots and have been running into this issue with every one. Within After Effects CC 2019, my composition looks fine, but once the shot is rendered, it looks as though the blending mode changes (either set to Add or Classic Color Dodge). This seems like a color space issue but I have no idea how to approach solving it.

The footage is all 2592x2160 Quicktime Movs and the project itself is the same, 32 bpc. These shots were rendered in Media Encoder to H.264, Match Source, Maximum Depth and Render Quality, CBR 480, and a Key Frame Distance of 1.