Skip to main content
dissidently
Inspiring
July 17, 2013
Question

Why is it not possible to separate the dimensions of the top position in a rectangle?

  • July 17, 2013
  • 2 replies
  • 25840 views

See the screen shot below.


Because I'm using a repeater I'd like to separate the dimensions for finer animation control up in this top Position of the Rectangle.

Why is this not possible?

This topic has been closed for replies.

2 replies

JamAttack
Participant
May 4, 2022

These replies don't actually work. I found a much better way, just make a null object and tie the effect position to the position of that null. When all else fails: null objects.

 

You can then effect the position of this null using sliders if you want and not have a brain aneurysm ok bye

Community Expert
July 17, 2013

Not there. Can only do that in the transform property. You should add a feature request.

dissidently
Inspiring
July 17, 2013

Has nobody ever requested this before?

Participant
December 3, 2013

> Has nobody ever requested this before?

very few


Just to add to the votes, I NEED to be able to separate X and Y in ALL of the position properties, not just in the "Transform" sub-menu.

I'm trying to get realistic character animation, Pixar style, as per my training through Animation Mentor and experience beyond.

But I can't do exactly what I need with, for instance, the Puppet Pin Tool because I can't separate X and Y.

Even something simple like the bouncy ball - as per this video - http://tv.adobe.com/watch/learn-after-effects-cs4/animating-precisely-with-separate-dimensions/

If I make my ball connected to a Puppet Pin, I can't properly animate a bouncy ball. Imagine that difficulty multiplied as I apply the same problem to a full character rig with arms and legs. It seems pointless having the Pin tool at all if I can't properly control it.

This is a big problem, as I've been using Adobe steadily for six years since CS3, and I've just discovered the graph editor has been removed from Flash, per CC. Where else can I go if not at least to AE?

If I can't get these controls over my animation, I'd have to either animate frame-by-frame, or move over to another product, which would be a shame because I love Adobe and I know it's possible.

I know I'm in a minority, but PLEASE consider adding the "Separate Dimensions" functionality to ALL aspects (I'd even wish for it on rotation, scale, etc.) I would find this not only extremely useful but actually necessary to do what I am trying to do.

Thanks,

ianalexh (Animated Critic).