Quitter
  • Communauté internationale
    • Langue:
      • Deutsch
      • English
      • Español
      • Français
      • Português
  • 日本語コミュニティ
  • 한국 커뮤니티

Not Snapping to Zero Crossings?

Engagé ,
Jan 06, 2025 Jan 06, 2025

I have Snapping set up with everything unchecked except for Zero Crossings. But the edges of a selection snap to tons of different places in between zero crossings. I can't figure out what it IS snapping to. 

 

In this image, I dragged to create a selection, and I expected the edges of the selection to snap only to zero crossings (I marked the edges of a selection, which are clearly NOT zero crossing points). But as you can see, this didn't happen.

 

What am I missing here? Is there a way to have AA ONLY snap to zero crossings and nothing else?

KenTheriot_0-1736205605131.png

 

SUJETS
Guide pratique
636
Traduire
Signaler
Directives de la communauté
Restez bienveillant et courtois, ne vous attribuez pas la paternité des créations d’autrui et assurez-vous de l’absence de doublons avant de poster du contenu. En savoir plus
community guidelines

correct answers 1 bonne réponse

Community Expert , Sep 23, 2025 Sep 23, 2025

For some reason I didn't look at the video - but when I did, the reason for this was obvious; he hadn't checked 'enabled' at the top of the snapping list, so it wouldn't work anyway - it takes two checks to enable any of the snapping options.

Traduire
Community Expert ,
Jan 07, 2025 Jan 07, 2025

If there are no zero crossing points in your selection, then it's not possible to snap to them!

Traduire
Signaler
Directives de la communauté
Restez bienveillant et courtois, ne vous attribuez pas la paternité des créations d’autrui et assurez-vous de l’absence de doublons avant de poster du contenu. En savoir plus
community guidelines
Engagé ,
Jan 07, 2025 Jan 07, 2025

I get that. And yeah, that screen pic could have been better. But my point is that if the ONLY thing it is set to snap to are zero crossings, how am I able to create a selection between 2 crossings? In most programs if you don't drag far enough to include a thing that is supposed to be snapped to, you won't be able to create a selection between them. the edges of the selection jump to the snap points as you cross them. But before that, there is no selection. However, I can see as I drag to create the above selection that the edges are snapping to SOMETHING that is NOT zero crossings. So how/why is that possible when I told it not to snap to anything but zero crossings. I hope this is making sense. I'll make a video later today.

Traduire
Signaler
Directives de la communauté
Restez bienveillant et courtois, ne vous attribuez pas la paternité des créations d’autrui et assurez-vous de l’absence de doublons avant de poster du contenu. En savoir plus
community guidelines
Community Expert ,
Jan 07, 2025 Jan 07, 2025

If it's a stereo waveform, all bets are off...

Traduire
Signaler
Directives de la communauté
Restez bienveillant et courtois, ne vous attribuez pas la paternité des créations d’autrui et assurez-vous de l’absence de doublons avant de poster du contenu. En savoir plus
community guidelines
Engagé ,
Jan 07, 2025 Jan 07, 2025

It's mono. One thing that might help describe the issue is that if I am dragging the edge of a selection as it approaches the zero crossing, it will continue to snap incrementally (why it's snapping and what it's snapping to I still don't know) and often willsnap to a point just left or right of the actual crossing. You can still see space.

Traduire
Signaler
Directives de la communauté
Restez bienveillant et courtois, ne vous attribuez pas la paternité des créations d’autrui et assurez-vous de l’absence de doublons avant de poster du contenu. En savoir plus
community guidelines
Engagé ,
Jan 10, 2025 Jan 10, 2025

Okay, I made a video that I think should clarify this problem I'm having. https://app.screencast.com/3pCeTvbzbTG3A It would be so great to have it actually snap to ONLY Zero crossings - would save me a ton of time.

Traduire
Signaler
Directives de la communauté
Restez bienveillant et courtois, ne vous attribuez pas la paternité des créations d’autrui et assurez-vous de l’absence de doublons avant de poster du contenu. En savoir plus
community guidelines
Nouveau ici ,
Sep 23, 2025 Sep 23, 2025

did you find a solution?

Traduire
Signaler
Directives de la communauté
Restez bienveillant et courtois, ne vous attribuez pas la paternité des créations d’autrui et assurez-vous de l’absence de doublons avant de poster du contenu. En savoir plus
community guidelines
Community Expert ,
Sep 23, 2025 Sep 23, 2025

For some reason I didn't look at the video - but when I did, the reason for this was obvious; he hadn't checked 'enabled' at the top of the snapping list, so it wouldn't work anyway - it takes two checks to enable any of the snapping options.

Traduire
Signaler
Directives de la communauté
Restez bienveillant et courtois, ne vous attribuez pas la paternité des créations d’autrui et assurez-vous de l’absence de doublons avant de poster du contenu. En savoir plus
community guidelines
Nouveau ici ,
Sep 23, 2025 Sep 23, 2025

I'm trying to find a function in RX8 which allows me to nudge the playhead to the next zero crossing.

Traduire
Signaler
Directives de la communauté
Restez bienveillant et courtois, ne vous attribuez pas la paternité des créations d’autrui et assurez-vous de l’absence de doublons avant de poster du contenu. En savoir plus
community guidelines
Engagé ,
Sep 23, 2025 Sep 23, 2025

Woooooow. That is not intujitive. But I see it now. Thanks!

Traduire
Signaler
Directives de la communauté
Restez bienveillant et courtois, ne vous attribuez pas la paternité des créations d’autrui et assurez-vous de l’absence de doublons avant de poster du contenu. En savoir plus
community guidelines
Engagé ,
Sep 23, 2025 Sep 23, 2025
LA PLUS RÉCENTE

Yes. See SteveG's response below. 

Traduire
Signaler
Directives de la communauté
Restez bienveillant et courtois, ne vous attribuez pas la paternité des créations d’autrui et assurez-vous de l’absence de doublons avant de poster du contenu. En savoir plus
community guidelines