Eyelids not working properly in side views

[jbsthd]

I have a puppet with different head views. The eyelids on one of the eyes behave oddly in any of the side views (puppet attached). The layer structure is as follows:

Here's a screen shot of the bevaiour:

The tags seem to be applied correctly to the layers

[TheOriginalGC]

it's hard to see what's causing the situation, but the positioning of the eyelids is off. The bottom one is too far up and the top one is too far down. Is this meant to blink? 

[jbsthd]

The eyeballs and pupils are fine. It's just the eyelids that are acting wonky

[jbsthd]

What you are seeing in the screenshot is the improper behaviour of the eyelids in the right eye. The left eye is fine despite the fact the lids are positioned the same on both eyes.

[TheOriginalGC]

Would it be possible to share the puppet using a file sharing service like google drive or drop box?

[jbsthd]

Can I share it directly with you?

[TheOriginalGC]

If you prefer, you can share the link in a DM with me.