Generative Fill Restrictions: this is just getting silly...

[default06m957uada4e]

I wanted to make a 'fist surrounded by a nimbus of power' using Generative Fill in AI. It told me I was violating user guidlelines. I tried just 'Fist' by itself and was told te same thing, so I know it is not 'Nimbus' or 'Power' causing the problems.

That is seriously ridiculous.

As a game designer, who designs material for games that involve fighting at times, this makes Adobe AI products pretty useless. As a professor who is teaching about AI and art, I've actually switched to DALL-E for the class, because Firely was to restrictive to let my students genreate material for their projects. 

You have got to find a better balance between actual serious harm and putting rubber baby buggy bumpers on everything in existence. Let people be adults for goodness sakes...

[Monika Gause]

I don't know what you mean by "nimbus of power", but I had no problems generating a fist.

But also I entered the prompt in German.

If you think the deny is wrong, then please report it via https://illustrator.uservoice.com 

[default06m957uada4e]

Wow! That worked! I mean, it only has three fingers, and you'd break your thumb if you hit somebody like that, but otherwise, that's a pretty good fist.

Guess I'm going to have to try all my difficult requests in German from now on...

[Monika Gause]

Firefly understands 100 languages. Google Translate does as well.

[Kurt Gold]

I also get German fists. Sometimes with three fingers, sometimes with five fingers. And six fingers are also there sometimes. Formidable.

As for your question: Does that seem right to you?

Yes, of course. The entire cosmos desperately needs German fists.

Here is what I get when asking Illustrator for dancing German fists in the universe. Marvelous.

[default06m957uada4e]

Das ist fantastisch! Lol!

[Jacob Bugge]

default06,

When the first nanny filter appeared here in 2009 it was forbidden to mention the Live Paint Bucket Tool, until some of us mentioned that it made helping difficult.

In the first many years, the nanny filter consistently went for words that might have a rude meaning in American English, even those with an innocent main meaning such as the common (other) word for a donkey, whereas the corresponding unambiguously rude (taboo slang) British English word would pass unnoticed.

Those days are (at least mostly) over, but it seems that non English words may still be too tough to handle for the Generative Fillter.