Issues with indentation in Bullets and Numbering

[ashimg23377171]

Hello

I've been facing issues with indentation of bullets. The foll is an example. The text on the second line of the bullet does not align with the first line.

I've been able to get it to work sometimes by ensuring that the 'left indent' and 'first line indent' negate each other... but im clearly missing sthg... for that approach doesn't work always, as in this case where the second line is aligning almost with this first line... however, the bullet has been bumped to the left margin... and trying to change the 'tab position' just doesn't help.

Any guidance on the right workflow for this would be appreciated.

Regards

[winterm]

Your Tab Position should be equal to Left Indent. That's it.

[ashimg23377171]

Thank you, but im afraid that doesn't work.

[winterm]

That’s the way Bullets and Numbering in InDesign works. If it doesn’t for you, look for the culprit somewhere else. I’d begin with applying standard bullets to a clean unformatted text, and see how it behave. If your styles are really ok, maybe there’s a minor file corruption and it’s worth to try trashing your prefs (yes, I hate offering this ).

[SJRiegel]

If it's file corruption (specific to this one file), trashing prefs is not the answer, but saving the file as IDML might help.

[winterm]

Oh, yes, you're right...

[Jeffrey_Smith]

Your settings should look like this:

[SJRiegel]

Or you can leave the Tab Position blank. The first line indent (In InDesign) also functions as a tab stop, so it's not needed unless you want your tab to fall to the left of the indent. 

[Barb Binder · Accepted solution]

Oh hello!

winterm is correct when he says your tab should be equal to the left indent. Here's a little more info:

1. Use the left indent to set up the left side of the entire bullet paragraph.
2. Use a negative right indent first line indent to pull the bullet back out towards the margin—partway or all the way
3. Use the left indent value for your tab position (or leave it blank and it will default to the left indent value)

So if the left indent is 18 pt, set the tab to 18 pts or leave it blank:

(I prefer to measure in points. In your case both should be 0.3125")

[ashimg23377171]

Thanks v much, everyone for weighing in.

I got it to work.

[Migintosh]

"Use a negative right indent to pull the bullet back out towards the margin—partway or all the way"

I think you meant to say negative Left indent.

[Barb Binder]

ugh. I meant negative first line indent.

[29632062lql3]

Hi @Barb Binder   A quick follow-up please.

I am unable to quite visualize what the following means:

1. Use a negative  first line indent to pull the bullet back out towards the margin—partway or all the way

Can someone please break it down for me.

Thanks!

[LyrJet]

If you are setting the left indent at 18pt, it'll push the bullet and following lines right by 18 pt. If you want the type to line up on the left margin, you need to then apply a negative indent of 18 pt (so, -18 pt) to pull the first line back to the left. This should align the type and leave the bullet on its own to the left. Does that make sense?

[29632062lql3]

oh gosh... i'm afraid, no. but i guess that's got to do with some mental block that is preventing me from figuring this one.

So: 

1. Use the left indent to set up the left side of the entire bullet paragraph.
2. Use a negative first indent first line indent to pull the bullet back out towards the margin—partway or all the way

The way i am thinking about these two steps (for certain, erroneously) is that i am negating my first operation. Why do i need to pull the bullet back to the margin (negative first line indent) when i have pushed it away from the margin (left indent).

Thanks for your time.

[BobLevine]

Because that's how it works.

Instead of trying to visualize it, why don't you try it? That will bring it all into focus.

[29632062lql3]

🙂 I tried it, and it certainly works fine.

But I can't understand why do i have to the do first line indent as a negation of the left indent.

[Bevi Chagnon - PubCom]

Because the "back-dent" (negative number) is what creates the hanging bullet. It positions the bullet character outside the text area in the white space.

This is the programming method developed 40+ years ago in the original typesetting and desktop publishing programs way back then, and it still works very well in today's programs. Let's us designers control the exact placement and alignment of the bullet character and the text.

As Bob above said, that's just the way it works.

[Nike T]

Followed winterm​'s advice and looked for the culprit elsewhere. Turned out it was a rectangle shape with wrapping around the boundary box that I'd placed next to the text box. Once I moved it away from the text box a little bit, the alignment was fixed. Thanks! Was driving me nuts and I've got a deadline.

[LyrJet]

I was having issues with this as well. I would get my alignment for my nested numbered list set perfectly, but then when I moved into double digit numbers, it got wonky. The solution ended up being a combination of the responses here plus selecting "Alignment: Right." Finally, I'm all set!