Participant

Question

InDesign is really made for ePub ?

Forum|Forum|6 years ago
February 23, 2020
4 replies
3675 views

Hi !

I try to export a simple book (novel) to ePub 2.0.1 for a week on Indesign 15.0.1 on Windows.

I followed many tutorials, read blog posts, help etc. And I am more confusing each day!

Maybe the software was not really tested for ePub compilation or I'm doing really something wrong at each step.

I made a new document (not book) with a primary text frame.

I just put the book title, copyright page and 2 chapters to test it.

I made a paragraph style for the chapter title and I have already some bugs!

For the export option :

- epub 2.0.1 / reflowable

- cover none

- navigation toc : file name

- Content order : Based on page layout

- Split documents : Based on paragraph style export tags

1) on adobe digital edition => unable to add the document... Great ! the document is made on adobe software and it doesn't work on another adobe software.

2) on Liberty (epub reader for windows) the software crash as soon as check "split document (epub only) on export tagging for the Chapter Title paragraph style (tag:h1 / class: chapter-title / emit Css : checked

3) on calibre (another epub reader for windows) it didn't crash but the text is not appearing because Calibre uses dark mode (black background) and the font color generated by indesign is black...

So I continue with Google book. I import and the text appears and it didn't crash. \o/

But the title placement is off... No space between title book and copyright page.

So I right-click on the title page block text > Object export option.

I checked Custom layout : center and insert page break after image.

I do the same for the copyright page.

4) result ok on Google play book but the title page is always stick with the copyright page. No page break on Icecream Ebook reader...

At this step, I just hope my readers don't use any epub reader on windows and continue with Google play book. Then I have some bugs with page break after and before image I cannot reproduce on my file test which I join here.

I also use Scrivener (little software for writing) to export a epub file, and I don't have all these bugs.

No crash, the text is automatically white on dark background, each laminar page is on a separate page. So why I don't use this soft instead of Indesign ? Because it doesn't have many options for layout.

If I made something wrong please tell me.

If you have a indesign document for book which works on windows, I will be really pleased to test it.

I test a template for the same results.

Thanks for any help.

test001.zip

This topic has been closed for replies.

Willi Adelberger

Community Expert

Before you start to make EPUBs with InDesign, you should learn some basics. Your document is deletantic. There are so many basic errors, you should avoid, not only for EPUBs, but also for simply typesetting:

You did not work with styles. No Paragraph Styles, no Character Styles, no Object Styles, except for the Chapter Headlines. Working without Styles is ridiculous.
Your stories are neither linked nor added to the articles in order.
You use succeeding returns to get space from top or between paragraphs. This is a no-go in print files and an absolute no-go with EPUBs. In EPUBs multiple returns will be simply ignored, don't do that.

Jongware

Community Expert

In other words, there is truth in "it's a poor workman who blaims his tools".

T

toojeematAuthor

Participant

@Gusgsm : thanks I test it, but everething was ok.

@rayek_elfin : you had right. I watched the course "InDesign CC 2018: EPUB" from Lynda.com (4h35) and I don't learned so much... At the end of the course, I taked the epub from the last exercise files and test it on Calibre, Liberty and some other readers and the same bugs had appeared... So I officially abandon InDesign.
I looked Jutoh, and man, it seems so complicated ! I mean I know I can do stuff with some time but... pff.
Before watch, read, experiment many tutorials / courses on Jutoh I looked if it does all I needed. And... it doesn't export to PDF...

So I did what I should do from the beginning : install Virtuabox to run macOS Sierra on Windows. Why ? Because I installed Vellum and I was able to export epub, pdf, mobi in 15min ! The bugs from InDesign disappear and everything worked nicely ! The major issue with Vellum is : you can't custom things as you want. But the styles incorporated are really beautiful, so why bother too much ?

Test Vellum, you'll win a lot of time and effort.
Everything is thinking for novel.
You even have preview in real time for kindle, ipad, android tablet, nook and print.

Gusgsm

Inspiring

I suggest you to use an epub validation tool. There are some online and/or free like epub validator or epubcheck. They might help you by hinting where your troubles are. Besides, a validated epub is a happy publisher 😉

Hope it helps

BobLevine

Community Expert

For starters, why are you using 2.0? That's an archaic EPUB format. What version of InDesign? Have you had any training at all in this? There's nothing intuitive about it. You need to prepare an InDesign file very precisely and that means styles for everything and a single text flow.

T

toojeematAuthor

Participant

I tried ePub 2.0 or 3.0 for the same result.

I look what other writers uses and I see 2.0 even for their latest novel, so I pick the same for the maximum compatibility.

I'm using Indesign CC 15.0.1 64bits.

I use single text flow for the test file, but for my real novel file, I also style everything, use articles to establish an order of pages, try dozens of settings, watch many tutorials, etc.

I uploaded a simple file to show you what the problems are even with a tiny project.

rayek.elfin

Legend

For reflowable epubs, consider the switch to Jutoh (or even Sigil). These are dedicated epub editors.

While InDesign can be used, it requires a very careful workflow since InDesign's core architecture is meant for visual (fixed) page layouts, and rather not for reflowable epub layouts. It always feels as if I am swimming against the flow when I format reflowable epubs in InDesign.

Many InDesign features cannot be used, and have to be avoided. It is also not possible to preview the result immediately, or control/inspect the underlying code directly. InDesign's code is also rather fragile, but generally that doesn't pose too many issues. Jutoh has real-time error validation, and even Sigil has a built-in epub code validator. This is important for debugging and with InDesign the user is forced to export an epub and use external validation tools - which is a real workflow breaker.

Another issue is that InDesign hides the underlying content structure of an epub, while Jutoh and Sigil expose it in a sidebar. Not possible in InDesign. And as Bob states, you will have to work in a single text flow, while Jutoh and SIgil allow you to work in separated chapter files, for example, and manage audio, video, and images in folders within the project itself.

Anyway, if a reflowable epub is your output format, at the very least use Sigil to check and validate your InDesign exported epub. Sigil is free. Jutoh is not, but I prefer it over InDesign for this type of job. InDesign is too fragile to work with in my own experience.

http://www.jutoh.com/

https://sigil-ebook.com/

PS If you are expecting Jutoh to be similar to InDesign, you will be disappointed. The workflow is targeted toward epub, and you will have to adjust accordingly.

Sign up

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Sign in to Adobe Community

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Scanning file for viruses.

This file cannot be downloaded