InDesign Tables breaking across pages for no apparent reason

Running into this behavior throughout a catalog I'm working on. When there's more than enough room left on the page, it keeps kicking the last row of the table onto the next page. If I highlight all cells and go to Cell Options, Rows and Columns, and tick "keep with next row," it throws the entire table on the next page, leaving a huge gap on the page where it could've fit the whole thing. What option do I inadvertently have selected that's making this happen? See image