Lightroom Classic: Processed RAW images removing edits and showing "Camera Raw Settings" in the history state

Just a thought, are you using Adobe Camera Raw to do edits outside of Lightroom and then updating Lightroom when you get a warning message?

Did you ever figure this out? I'm having the same issue. Thanks!

Have you considered resetting the preferences file:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=bARt-hoCc2Q

In the back of my head the History State “Multiple Settings” occurs when you copy Develop settings from one image to one or more other images.

No, I do not have a link to back that up.

Not sure if that comes across from sync via Mobil.

But the Camera RAW one?? Google search has been not so helpful

Thank you all for your responses. Here's a batch set of answers

To clear up some of the confusion: LR CC is saving my edits, but it is adding new edits on top of my old ones. These are labeled as 'Multiple Settings' followed by several 'Camera Raw Settings' in the LR History panel. The entries for Camera Raw Settings appear to be all the same for each picture, but the edits can be different for different pictures. For example, on one picture, the Camera Raw Settings entry removes the saturation. On another it resets the cropping.

1) Lightroom is up to date (8.3.1)

2) This occurs on both my Nikon and Fuji Raw Images

3) I'm not importing originals again. I import the images once, then never import again. All of the effected images seem to be in collections that I sync to LR Mobile. I use an LR mobile on an I-pad.

4) I looked at my metadata settings and all three boxes are checked (i.e., offer suggestions from recently entered values, include develop settings in metadata inside JPEG, TIFF, ..., and automatically write changes into XMP).

I am lucky that I can get back to the edit I liked, but it's frustrating having to scan the develop settings for each image (this has affected 100s of images).

Any help would be most appreciated.

TS

My first guess was that you were exporting and overwriting the original. Make sure you're not doing that! Do you by any chance use the automatic metadata saving to files or synchronize your folder the images are in in Classic?

I’ve not seen this. But the history will relate to the original file not an exported file. Are you adding expoted files back into the catalog. Or are you syncing a smart preview from a collection and then re-importing the original via Lightroom Mobile?

Hi Todds,

Sorry that Lightroom Classic is not saving your raw images with all the edits. Do you see what all changes occur on the overall look of the image when go through each history state item of "Camera Raw" ?

Which version of Lightroom Classic are you using? Latest is 8.3.1(Check under Help>>System info)

Also, does the issue occurs with a specific raw image or camera/lens type?

Thanks,

Akash