Skip to main content
Participant
February 19, 2018
Question

Lightroom Resizing Photos Problem

  • February 19, 2018
  • 5 replies
  • 2313 views

So when I resize my photos to the size I need for my website using Lightroom Classic CC v7.2 the photos are very soft. I'm exporting RAW photos to JPEG using sRGB color, image quality at 80. Then resizing them to Long Edge at 1,000 pixels, 72 resolution. I've tried everything and can not figure this out, when I don't resize the image to the size I need and export it with all the other previous settings the image is clear, it only happens when resizing. HELP!

This topic has been closed for replies.

5 replies

Per Berntsen
Community Expert
Community Expert
February 21, 2018

What is the resolution of your display (in pixels)?

If you have a Retina display, web browsers will scale everything, including images to 200%.

This is to compensate for the small pixel size, and to ensure that everything is displayed at a "normal" size.

I don't use a Mac, but suspect that native apps, like Mac Preview, do the same thing.

There are methods to get around this problem in web browsers, which include uploading two versions of the image to the website. The second version will typically have double pixel dimensions, and the file name will be appended with @2x - like image@2x.jpg.

The website will need to be coded to enable the @2x images to be used, and the result is that the browser will display the @2x image without scaling it on Retina displays, while the regular image will be displayed on regular, non-Retina screens.

richardplondon wrote

For example: say a system was designed to deduce a supposed printing size for each image, and then to generate a screen viewing version to a standard resolution based on that supposed printing size.

One can imagine two versions of the same image being input to such a system, varying only in their PPI:

image 1000x500px @ 300ppi; interpreted as 3.33 inches wide; this resampled @ 72ppi = 240px wide preview image

image 1000x500px @ 72ppi; interpreted as 13.89 inches wide; this resampled @ 72ppi = 1000px wide preview image.]

This is more or less how Indesign works, since it is used for creating printed documents, it uses the ppi to preview the printed size of an image. But web browsers don't care about ppi, they display images according to their pixel dimensions.

Participant
February 19, 2018

Here are the screen captures of the the same image they are both JPEGs and exported in Lightroom the only difference is the sizing. Which is what I need to export them at for my works website and to also clear up some confusion when another co-worker exports his photos under the same settings they are nowhere near as soft as mine. Also if you take one of my photos off the website and put it into photoshop it becomes much clearer. The top pic is soft and the bottom pic is clear using preview.

Per Berntsen
Community Expert
Community Expert
February 19, 2018

The top image is obviously viewed at a magnification higher than 1:1.

The screenshot is over 2000 pixels wide, and you exported it at 1000 pixels, so you're viewing it at 2:1, which accounts for the softness.

View the image at 1:1 (100%), and it will look OK.

If you want the image to display this size (2000 pixels), you have to export at 2000 pixels.

Participant
February 19, 2018

No importing the original RAW files into lightroom and then resizing them in lightroom and then exporting them in JPEG format resized to the 1000pix.

Per Berntsen
Community Expert
Community Expert
February 19, 2018

Are you applying output sharpening in the Export dialog?

Try sharpening for screen, amount Standard.

When you resize an image, it will become softer, and output sharpening is designed to compensate for this.

Participant
February 21, 2018

So let's see the two images both at 1:1 magnification.


Alright so I can't really take a screen capture of both photos 1:1 since my photo export with no resizing is 4288x2848 and will only show like the front bumper of my photo at 100%, while the dimensions of the resized photo is 1000x664. But to continue further explanations: so when I pull one of my "soft" resized photos off the website and then put that same photo into Photoshop it becomes much clearer. Why would that be? It's still the same dimensions, just not as soft. Also my coworkers photos with no resizing is 5212x2848 and has to be resized to 1000x664 (the same size as mine has to go to) and they are much clearer. I'm really lost here.

dj_paige
Legend
February 19, 2018

When they look soft, what magnification are you using to view the photos? What software are you using to view the photos? Show us a screen capture of the not-soft photo as seen in Lightroom, and another screen capture of the soft photo as seen outside of Lightroom 

JP Hess
Inspiring
February 19, 2018

Do you mean that you are exporting them as JPEG's first, and then resizing them? Why not export from the raw files and resize them in one single operation if that's not what you're doing?