P: Color artifacts in JPEG XL ProPhoto RGB

Forum|Forum|1 year ago
June 13, 2024
14 replies
10165 views

JPEG XL files with the ProPhoro RGB color space exported from Lightroom contain color compression artifacts. They appear in quality 100% and lower. Other color spaces do not have this problem.

Lightroom version 13.3.1

Windows 11 23H2 version 22631.3593

Windows

Show previous replies

apf102

Known Participant

Thanks. Have replied on the other forum too.

RE the bug. I can make the artefacts appear if I export to JXL in Rec2020 16bit with quality set to 100%. It is only the uncompressed exports which seem to be fine. 8 bit also fine.

apf102

Known Participant

Weird artefacts with jpeg xl exports + advice on best export format

expectated behaviour - high quality jxl file

actual behaviour - file has blocky artefacts and weird colour shifts

Lr Classic 13.5.1 in Win 11 and Lr 9.5.1 on iPad

Hi. Two quick questions.

1) Does anyone know why I am getting these weird red artefacts on my Jxl exports? This is viewed on Lr Cc on my iPad. Original file was a NEF of a film negative. It was converted in negative lab pro. You can see the NEF displays fine. If I export from the NEF to a jxl I get similar red artefacts, though less pronounced. Other formats are fine. The jxl settings were 16bit compressed at 100% quality in ProPhoto colour space from LR Classic on Pc.

2) this is a workflow question. I tend to import and convert film negatives in Lightroom Classic, but for various reasons I like to edit on my iPad. This means the best workflow is to create a positive image for editing on iPad and getting rid of the raw (I have the negative so no biggy). I had been exporting to sRGB JPEG but was getting weird results when printing and of course you lose a load of depth.. Tiffs are way too large to use. The plan was to use 16bit jxl maybe with ProPhoto colour space, which seems to be about 25mb, but am getting the issue described above.

Any ideas much welcomed!

johnrellis

Legend

Re the workflow question, see my suggestion for syncing the NEFs with LR Cloud and then LR Mobile on the Ipad:

https://www.lightroomqueen.com/community/threads/workflow-issues-with-jxl-and-lightroom-classic.51142/#post-1340444

johnrellis

Legend

Re color artifacts in JPEG XL ProPhoto RGB exports, Adobe has acknowledged this bug:

https://community.adobe.com/t5/lightroom-classic-bugs/p-color-artifacts-in-jpeg-xl-prophoto-rgb/idi-p/14678954

The color spaces Display P3 and Rec 2020 don't appear to have the problem.

Rick Spaulding -

Legend

Update: Recommendations:

If using lossy compression, prefer using JXL-native color spaces such as sRGB, Display P3, or Rec 2020.
If you must use non-native color spaces such as Adobe RGB or ProPhoto, consider using Lossless (quality 13).