Skip to main content
Sauron84
Sauron84
Participant
September 6, 2020
Answered

Panorama HDR highlight blown

  • September 6, 2020
  • 4 replies
  • 928 views

When creating a vertical hdr panorama of 4 photo, each one of them composed by 5 photo in hdr, I've highlight blown even if the information are all there in the underexposed shots. It seems like lightroom, when clicking hdr panorama tries to uniform the shot by lifting the shadows and burning the highlights of the composed photo. I've already checked that when clicking hdr panorama the "automatic settings" is NOT selected. Attached you can find the result. I've also tried first to created the single hdr, and then creating the panorama but the results are the same...

Correct answer Sauron84

I've found a solution by myself, as usual Adobe Customer Support wasn't helpful... So you need to create the hdr from the single files, then tune them to have an average exposure (recover the highlights and lift the shadows...). Then you need to open the HDR files created in Photoshop and create a panorama. I don't know why if you do this in LR it will blow your highlights...

4 replies

Sauron84
Sauron84AuthorCorrect answer
Participant
September 9, 2020

I've found a solution by myself, as usual Adobe Customer Support wasn't helpful... So you need to create the hdr from the single files, then tune them to have an average exposure (recover the highlights and lift the shadows...). Then you need to open the HDR files created in Photoshop and create a panorama. I don't know why if you do this in LR it will blow your highlights...

Y
yoeldiamante
Participating Frequently
September 7, 2022

thanks for sharing. i will try.

    GoldingD
    GoldingD
    Legend
    September 6, 2020

    3. Most selected photo. When you select all the photos to merge, try changing the most selected photo. I do not know what exposure may work best, but if your exposure bracket is from under exposed to overexposed, perhaps the default most selected photo is an underexposed one, and I suspect that would not be helpful, maybe change to the center one.

     

    Sauron84
    Sauron84Author
    Participant
    September 6, 2020

    Hi, thanks for answering 🙂

    1) I've tried both, no editing and also tried to balance every file recovering highlights and lifting shadows...but lr hdr panorama seems to ignore those settings...

    2) Good idea, I didn't know that! Unfortunately I've tried but the result is the same...highlights burnt....

    3) I'm using 5 shots from a DJI drone, the order LR import those photos is: overexposed shot, correct shot, over-overexposed shot, very dark shot and most overexposed of the all the shots.

    GoldingD
    GoldingD
    Legend
    September 6, 2020

    2. A possible oddity

     

    Remember that Photo Merge HDR will present you with a screen with options like Auto Tone, prepopulated per how you used the Merge last.

     

    Now you do not see that screen in a Photo Merge HDR Panorama. So perhaps bring up a Photo Merge HDR, make sure Auto Tone is off, merge one, then go to Photo Merge HDR Panorama.

     

    Just a what if.

     

    GoldingD
    GoldingD
    Legend
    September 6, 2020

    1. I will not assume, instead I will ask.

     

    You are NOT making any edits to the master RAW photos before attempting the Photo Merge HDR Panorama, correct?

     

    Photo Merge in LrC should ignore any such edits, but what if?

     

    Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
    Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices