Adobe work with us here. You just pushed an update that makes a total mess of everyone presets, even though you were notified of problems during the beta. We all like new features but come on. Is this programming school?
First, presets are changed to XML without asking. Ok, I see where they're going with the more compatible format and it has potential. But it's like Adobe did not even bother to see if it worked. Sure favorites are cool, but along with them, we are stuck with even more clutter of default preset folders and no way to remove them even though your customers have been asking for years.
Worse, Presets are randomly out of order inside their folders. It does not even make sense the random they are arranged. It's chaos for the LR organization many of us have developed over the years.
Next, the "Show Lightroom Presets" button in preferences still goes to the old presets folder and the original presets are there but no longer show up in because Lightroom is looking for the converted XML presets that are now in the Camera Raw folder. You didn't even bother to update the button? From what I can tell new presets installed in that official location will not only not show up, there is no way to convert them after the initial update.
I have thousands of photographers using preset packs I design. At this time I'm going to downgrade my working projects and recommend that people do not update until we have a solution for these blatant issues. I'll start tinkering for a temporary solution and everyone, please share if you have any until Adobe fixes this. Thanks.
I was able to find the XMP converted presets from the preset panel, by Right Click, Show in Finder/Explorer, they are in a new location:
The XMP files can be organized and display correctly in Explorer, but it does not solve the problem within Lightroom.
I think this is related to an index.dat file in ..\AppData\Roaming\Adobe\CameraRaw\Settings
I have a file named Index_A9977BC324D45582.dat and another named Index.dat.
Index.dat is garbage, it holds the path to some random xml file.
Index_A9977BC324D45582 seems to hold the names of all the preset files and folders in the order they're displayed in Lightroom.
So glad you pointed out where the presets are now stored (C:\Users\XXXX\AppData\Roaming\Adobe\CameraRaw\Settings)! I had to reinstall lightroom and couldnt work out why my presets werent loading in. Once I copied my backup of the the CameraRaw Settings data they loaded in. Thank you!
with me they are not stored in Camera raw
I activated the option to store everything with the catalog and so they are here:
old: (catalogfolder)/Lightroom-Einstellungen/Develop Preset
new: (catalogfolder)/Lightroom-Einstellungen/Settings (here are the new xml.files)
BUT New presets are NOT shown in Develp Module ONLY in Library Module.
In Camera Raw / Settings there is an index_(div. numbers).dat file but this is from last Update in June. And there ist a very old file index.dat from 2012. There is nothing more in the folder under camera raw.
So my conclusion: Develop and Library Module use different folders.
What a Mess!
I activated the option to store everything with the catalog ... BUT New presets are NOT shown in Develp Module ONLY in Library Module.
Hmm, I don't observe that behavior. When I create new presets, they show up both in Develop and Library. Some troubleshooting questions:
1. After you checked the option Store Presets With This Catalog, did you restart LR as it instructed?
2. Do the menu command Help > System Info. Are you running LR 7.4 or an earlier version? If you're running an earlier version, update to 7.4 and see if the problem still occurs.
If you're already on 7.4, then please file a bug report in the official Adobe feedback forum, where Adobe wants all bugs posted: Lightroom Classic CC | Photoshop Family Customer Community . Be sure to include the output from Help > System Info. Screenshots of Library showing the presets present and Develop showing them missing would also help,.
I am frustrated with the same problem.
I have the same problem - presets are after install LR 7.3 mixed and not alphabetical ordered like before. This is a huge problem, its possible to bring it back to normal alphabetical ordering?
Edit: renaming of all presets in new LR works... good luck to photographers with more presets 😕
(renaming in Windows not)
Yea the rename does seem to help but not sure if it sticks. I'm going to have to start renaming our packs I guess. Rename and then rename the same name and it sorts properly. What kind of programming style is this?
Regarding legacy presets. It looks like on conversion 7.3 adds a tilde ~ to the old presets and leave them in the original folder. If you add presets to the original presets folder without the tilde it does appear to update those new presets when Lightroom is restarted, which is a good thing for legacy presets. They will still be out of order of course.
7.3 is really still in beta and they are using us as a test I guess. I downgraded back to 7.2 for primary work, renamed it and installed 7.3 again for testing. You can do it from the CC window and the presets all went back to normal since 7.2 uses the original presets folder (and seems to ignore the tilde that 7.3 added). Backing up presets first could not hurt though.
Presets with tilde "~" are old - you can see new "settings folder" by clicking right on preset in LR and choosing "show in explorer". Its located now in "Adobe - CameraRAW - Settings", not in old Lightroom folder.
How did you downgrade?
You can just do it from the CC app window. There's a detail on how to downgrade in my blog post as well.
Try installing LR 7.3.1
there is no way in hell i will be installing 7.3.1 for at least a week until all the new bugs are found
I just installed 7.2 from the cc app over 7.3 an have everything back, meaning 7.2 with all my working presets 7.3 should have never have been released. Looks like a piece of *** in aplha state and newer been tested by anyone!
Oh, i'm sure it was tested heavily and their team found and knew of most these issues. Unfortunately, they had a hard delivery deadline of releasing for NAB and didn't fix these bugs in time.
Artificial deadlines apparently now take priority over messing with the livelihood of their subscribers whose jobs depend on using the Adobe suite.
I know for a fact they were made aware of the sorting bug because I was notified of the problem by a beta user who was talking to the team before release. They shipped it anyways, costing users thousands of hours of hassle and fixes. Adobe owes their users a serious apology.
Apologies are cheap. This snafu cost me money as I waste time looking for the presets. I read the release note thoroughly before updating. Nowhere was this mentioned. I want a refund for the month of April. I pay a subscription for regular, quality updates. Quality has just been dashed to the rocks and beaten senseless. It's going to be forever before I trust an Adobe update again. Hmmmm...On1, Luminar, Topaz, Photo Mechanic...starting to look attractive.
I'm having the same issue. My presets are hideously out of order now. This seems such a basic thing to have worked to avoid. It's also crashed twice since I installed it a half hour or so ago. Doesn't look ready for prime time to me.
I edited my xmp files that were out of order, and they did have a different value in crs:Name and crs:SortName.
I fixed the crs:SortName to match the Name (filename also) and now they are ordered correctly.
Good link Michael. Here's a comment on that thread that goes into good detail on what's happening. It's more detailed than the official response.. Lightroom Classic: Develop Presets Not Sorting Correctly (macOS - High Sierra) | Photoshop Family Cu...
I'm still blown away that Adobe would shipp this the update, ruining the experiance for so many without fixing the problem first. But untill they do it seems that this is what's happneing and we can fix it thru tedious renaming.
I suspect this error happened generations ago, when Lighroom first developed the .lrtemplate file format in the first place. They must have missed the alteration of the code if you create a preset and then rename it. Or, it's all our fault, for creating presets and then renaming them outside Lightroom. Not sure. Either way, it's gonna require hours of code-hunting to fix a whole collection of presets.
Same here and if I save a new preset it does not show up in my list, I can see it in the Mac finder , in the Camera Raw/Settings folder, but Lightroom won't show it...
For some reason, if I click "go to presets folder" in LR's preferences panel, it still takes me to the old Lightroom folder with all the .lrtemplate files, not the new CameraRaw folder. Only if I right-click an actual preset does it show the new .XMP file in the CameraRaw folder.
Also, my presets are out of order as well. Clearly, everybody who has ever made more than a handful of preset was using numbers to organize those presets, so I don't know how Adobe could have overlooked this numerical order bug.
The only thing I can think of is, these new .XMP files are getting sorted by DATE CREATED within Lightroom, for some reason? I had a similar problem when creating presets for Adobe Bridge, and then trying to use Finder / Explorer to rename those presets- ACR didn't recognize the new names.