Participating Frequently

Question

RAW+JPEG Imports

Forum|Forum|5 years ago
June 19, 2020
8 replies
3101 views

Hi,

I've just completed the upgrade to Lrc 9.3 - so using Lightroom Classic. My camera is a Fujifilm X-T4 and I shoot raw+jpeg and In the general preferences, I've always had the setting "treat JEPG files next to raw files as separate photos" unchecked (and it still is!), however since updating to 9.3, the import process is treating the jpeg file as a separate process.

I inserted a card that I had previously imported and Lightroom recognized all of the jpegs as not having being imported. I processed the card to see what would happen and it re-imported the jpegs with a -2 appended to the file name.

the Fuji is on the latest firmware

Lightroom is running on macOS Catalina 10.15.5

The device is a Macbook Pro 16" 2019 with 64GB ram and AMD Radeon Pro 5300M GPIU

Regards

Gerry

This topic has been closed for replies.

K

KDMizzle

Participant

Hello,

I started having the same issue with the EOS R since the Lightroom upgrade on an iMac. I just installed Lightroom on a Macbook Pro and I was not seeing the issue on import (RAWs and JPGs were shown as a single image).

I then setup a Metadata preset to apply on import (similar to what I do on my iMac) and it is now treating the raws and jpgs as separate images. If I turn off the Metadata preset when importing then the RAW and JPG images are treated as one file as desired.

Any chance you are applying metadata or develop settings on import? That might be the issue and if so I think its a bug.

Ken

Ian Aberle - SMU

Participant

I was having the same issue on my MacBook Pro (macOS High Sierra) with a Fuji X-T3. I think @KDMizzle hit on something. Turned off my Metadata preset and all of a sudden, it started treating the separate JPEG and RAW files as the same file. Turned back on the Metadata preset and it is continuing to treat them as the same file.

Definitely a bug.

Just Shoot Me

Legend

Has any one that is having this issue done a reset of the LrC preferences and then tested?

G

Gerry KerrAuthor

Participating Frequently

Hi

I can confirm that I have done a reset of the LrC preferences and the issue persists

Regards

Gerry

Just Shoot Me

Legend

Can you create a New Catalog, for testing (File menu item > New Catalog), and do some imports to it of a New shoot where you recorded both RAW and JPG on the same card (Same images) to see if it might be a problem with your original catalog.

michaelb.photography

Participant

Same issue. macOS Catalina version 10.15.5. LrC 9.3. First import since upgrade. Normally jpeg acts as sidecar in Library and only see one view with NEF+JPEG. Now I have both the JPEG and NEF raw files showing seperately.

Just Shoot Me

Legend

So to both of you.

You are on a Mac with the newest OS X. I'm usiing Windows.

So when the import window comes up it shows both the RAW and the JPG images in the center section?

If that is so for the time being just Sort: by File Type and Uncheck all the JPGs so they don't get imported.

If you want them in the same folder as the RAW files then Manually select and copy them into that same folder using Finder. that is until this problem get solved.

G

Gerry KerrAuthor

Participating Frequently

So... First off, apologies for not replying sooner - unfortunately, my day job got in the way this week 😞

So I've gone back to basics a bit

- Formatted a card

- Took some photos

- Imported them - everything looked normal

Went out and shot another couple of images without formatting the card

- took some photos

- imported them and the import dialog wanted to re-import all the jpgs ( see image).

The next screen capture shows the bottom section with the new photos

Just to be sure - here is the preferences section

If I let the import go ahead, all of the jpgs in the first capture get a -2 appended to the file name as they are in the library already

Can I also clarify that I do not have 2 cards inserted in the camera so all of the images (RAW+JPG) are stored on the same card and that my setup was working right up until i updated to 9.3

Thanks everyone who took the time to help

Regards

Gerry

M

michelh99476754

Participant

I Have the same issue, on MAC OS Catalina 10.15.5

Just Shoot Me

Legend

I have another question.

Are the JPG actually showing up in LrC when you are in the Grid View and have the Sort: set to Capture Time?

Just Shoot Me

Legend

I ask the above question because even with that LrC option unchecked, Treat JPGs as separate files, LR Still Copies the JPG images from the card and places them in the same folder as the RAW files and LrC actually makes a record of them in the LrC database file, the Catlaog file, as being imported but does not Display them in either the Grid view or Film strip. It does display the RAW + Jpg and marks the JPG as a Sidecar file.

Here is a screen shot of the LrC window with some shots I just took of my messy desk and imported them into LrC 9.3. You will see the JPGs are Not displayed and that it is listed as a sidecar file and the File name, as displayed at the top of the grid view thumbnails lists Raw file name and then + JPG. And then a screen shot of File Explorer showing the folder this import got copied to and the JPGs are next to the RAW files.

So the question is are you actually seeing the JPG images in LrC or just in a File Manager window?

When that option is not checked and there are JPG images, with the same file name except for the extension, on the same card as the RAW files LrC has always copied those JPGs into the same folder as the RAW files and entered a record of them in the catalog but does not display them. Also you can't then Import them as LrC knows you already imported them.

G

Gerry KerrAuthor

Participating Frequently

Hi

They are showing up in grid view and with the older card, even though all the images on the card had been ingested into LrC previously, it re-imported the jpgs again appending a -2 onto the file name

😞

Gerry

Just Shoot Me

Legend

Are the JPGs on a separate, Second In Camera, SD card? And do you connect the camera directly to the computer or use a card reader.

G

Gerry KerrAuthor

Participating Frequently

Hi,

jpgs are on the same card and yes, I'm connecting the camera via USB-C and downloading directly.

Thanks for responding

Gerry

Just Shoot Me

Legend

OK i have to ask again. Are you Sure the JPG aren't on the Second SD Card in the camera?

Fuji, I own 2 of them X-T2 and X-E2, has a setting in the camera to place RAW on one card and JPGs on the other, that is if the camera has 2 card slots. My T2 does and that is an option on the camera.

When the RAWs + JPGs are on 2 separate cards and you connect the camera directly to the computer LrC could be reading both cards and not seeing that the JPGs are the same files as the RAWs.

I also suggext you buy a card reader and stop connecting the camera directly to the computer.