Skip to main content
A
austinb88062669
Participant
February 15, 2021
Question

Real Estate Photography HDR Window Pulls

  • February 15, 2021
  • 6 replies
  • 3775 views

Hello!

 

I'm wanting to start a thread conerning HDR as it pertains to Real Estate Photography. LR Classic's HDR is my preferreed choice of inteior photo blending...as far as algorthim based HDR goes, it's the most clean interior image. Often times the HDR image that is produced is very dark thus the user must boost the exsposure by 1-2 (at least) Full Stops. And although the interior portion of the images look very sharp the windows are always blownout and very desaruated. I currently one possible solution to this issue without having to hand blend the widows manually in on Photoshop. 

 

If there isn't already a thing, I would LOVE a feature that automatically blends my lowest exsposure (window pull) to the HDR image after I have already applied my LR presets and adjuments. 

 

Adobe, I believe this would be a powerful tool for those of that need to save every second of time we can while editing extremely large batches of photos. If something like this already exists in Lightroom I would love to know or otherwise I would love to see if my idea is a possibility you can make happen and how I could help. 

 

Thank you!

 

-Austin

    This topic has been closed for replies.

    6 replies

    GoldingD
    GoldingD
    Legend
    February 2, 2022

    Two thoughts, will actually variations on one.

     

    If you apply a mask to the entire image, and use say a brush, you will find that your highlight range is expanded.

     

    Also, using that same mask, but intersecting with luminance range, you could exclude the widow from the mask, then open up the exposure.

     

      M
      Mechakoush
      Participant
      February 2, 2022

      Makes perfect sense what you are suggesting, will save lots of time for all of us in the field.

        Todd Shaner
        Todd Shaner
        Legend
        February 19, 2021

        Austin and Bob are correct. The Exposure control range was extended to +10 and -10.

         

        What I meant to say.....

        Adobe has extended the Exposure control range to by -5 and +5 so there should be no issue establishing the correct midtone exposure. I never needed anything close to the -10 and +10 Exposure range available for HDR DNG files.

        KR Seals
        Community Expert
        KR SealsCommunity Expert
        Community Expert
        February 18, 2021

        @Todd Shaner  I think the actual value of the exposure slider range in a LrC is -10 to +10.

        Ken Seals - Nikon Z 9, Z 8, 14mm-800mm. Computer Win 11 Pro, I7-14700K, 64GB, RTX3070TI. Travel machine: 2021 MacBook Pro M1 MAX 64GB. All Adobe apps.
        Bob Somrak
        Bob Somrak
        Legend
        February 18, 2021

        @KR Seals @Todd Shaner 

        Yes, it is +/- 10 on exposure.  WHY it is that large is the question.  Years ago when HDR was introduced I asked on the forums for anyone to upload an HDR that required +/-10.  I have never seen one. All this range does is reduce the accuracy of the slider.

        M4 Pro Mac Mini. 48GB
        Todd Shaner
        Todd Shaner
        Legend
        February 18, 2021

        Often times the HDR image that is produced is very dark thus the user must boost the exsposure by 1-2 (at least) Full Stops. And although the interior portion of the images look very sharp the windows are always blownout and very desaruated. I currently one possible solution to this issue without having to hand blend the widows manually in on Photoshop. 

         

        This is normal behavior for LrC Photo Merge HDR image files. Adobe has extendd the Exposure control range to -5 and +5 so there should be no issue establishing the correct midtone exposure. For the blownout highlights you should be applying -Highlights to -100 if necessary. When doing so it's best to set Shadows to the opposite and equal setting (-50 and +50). More here:

         

        https://helpx.adobe.com/lightroom-classic/help/tone-control-adjustment.html

         

        Bob Somrak
        Bob Somrak
        Legend
        February 15, 2021

        Go to the following link and download the Profile SDK.  You can creat a profile with expanded Highlights/Shadows sliders.  I created one called Adobe Color HDR for just the purpose of editing Lightroom HDR photos.  I dont use it on every HDR photo and on nonHDR photos it can create issues due to the expanded range (to be expected) but it works well on most HDR photos.  The SDK will give you fairly easy instrunction on how to create the profile in ACR.

         

        https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/digital-negative.html?mv=affiliate&mv2=red 

         

        M4 Pro Mac Mini. 48GB
          A
          austinb88062669Author
          Participant
          February 18, 2021

          Would this actually help blend in the correctly exsposed image from my bracket or just pull the shadows and highlights farther. What I want is Adobe to produce a window pull system that is applied AFTER the HDR is produced. 

            Bob Somrak
            Bob Somrak
            Legend
            February 18, 2021

            I dont know about this photos but I think if you do a lot of HDR the extended Tone Map Profile would help your work.

            M4 Pro Mac Mini. 48GB
            Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
            Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices