Skip to main content
A
Audiotechnical
Known Participant
February 11, 2021
Question

Adobe CC - 'Copy' the crop settings do not 'paste' as expected!

  • February 11, 2021
  • 1 reply
  • 2483 views

Those of us who have dreamed of an option to input numerical values for cropping images in Adobe Lightroom CC (having moved from Lightroom Classic), we have somehow managed to find ways around it. I thought selecting the 'Crop' option for my 'Edit Copy Settings' would work, however I have noticed that something unusual is happening, that I just cannot workout, and I'm not able to get the exact crop I want when exporting an image.

Let me clarify what I am trying to do, and maybe it will make my issue clearer.

I export portrait headshots regurlarly, and I need them to be very specific ratios/crops. I find a photo on my hard drive that I've already exported at (for example) 485x462px. I then find this photo inside my Library, and 'copy' the crop info. I paste it onto another photo, and export that photo. During exporting, I use the option for 'Long side' to be 485px. I would expect the output of the photo to be 485x462px, but nope, it comes out at 485x453px. This is suggesting that the crop I'm pasting is just not the ratio of the one I am copying from. In fact, I visually see this is the case, as when I paste, it seems to be in a portrait not landscape setup (although yes, it's almost a square).

 

Has anyone else found this to be an issue? Perhaps when it copies the Crop, it uses some kind of algorithm about the size/ratio of the 'uncropped' image (which does vary at times) and makes adjustments in respect of that. Who knows. But this is driving me nuts. 

 

Thanks for help in advance.

This topic has been closed for replies.

1 reply

JP Hess
JP Hess
Inspiring
February 11, 2021

When you crop specifying only the long side, Lightroom will ensure that the long side of the image will be the specified number of pixels. However, the short side will be relative to the number of pixels in the image. In other words, if the short side of the image isn't the exact number of pixels as the previous image that you cropped then it is unlikely that the short side of a new crop using the same long side specification will be exactly the same. If you need an image with both the long side and the short side with exactly the number of pixels then you need to specify both sets of numbers. But Lightroom could only produce an image that is 485x462 pixels if the short side is long enough to produce that.

A
AudiotechnicalAuthor
Known Participant
February 11, 2021

Oh, and I forgot to say (which may or may not be obvious, but even I've been slightly confused over the last couple of years, with Lightroom naming) that in Lightroom Classic, this is not an issue and I'm totally in control of that, but it is the newer Lightroom Desktop that I'm having the issue with.

JP Hess
JP Hess
Inspiring
February 12, 2021

I have never had to depend on exact crop dimensions when working with Lightroom. Frankly, I prefer working with Lightroom Classic because (at least for me) it seems to be more stable and much more dependable. I know there is a big user base that really likes the "new" Lightroom, and I'm not here to argue the merits of the two versions. I just prefer the "old" Lightroom Classic.

Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices