Skip to main content
P
Pawel287536848jwq
Known Participant
December 8, 2023
Question

Generative fill get worse and worse

  • December 8, 2023
  • 7 replies
  • 7015 views

Hello. Is it just my impression or are the images generated by both Adobe Firefly and Generative Fill in Photoshop really so pathetic and of poor quality that they cannot be used? In Photoshop you can't even change clothes using generative fill and if you can, it's far from what you wanted. The generated images are much worse than the initial Beta version of Photoshop.

    7 replies

    D
    Dominika2520361879ru
    Participant
    April 19, 2025

    This post has been created long time ago and now the things atre going just downhill. The gen AI (beta) is getting worse and worse- can't even perferom simple tasks. No idea what is happenig but its extremely frustrating. 

    c.pfaffenbichler
    Community Expert
    c.pfaffenbichlerCommunity Expert
    Community Expert
    April 21, 2025

    Please read this (in particular the section titled "Supply pertinent information for more timely and effective answers”):
    https://community.adobe.com/t5/using-the-community/community-how-to-guide-tips-amp-best-practices/td-p/11601738?page=1

     

    »is getting worse and worse« seems like a fairly useless description, please give meaningful examples and post screenshots to illustrate. 

    B
    bernardwerner
    Inspiring
    August 15, 2024

    Generative fill is not replicating the texture or resolution of the original. Attached is a 100% image of relatively calm water. Other attempts have included foliage from other parts of the image, what appears to be land, and other unidentifiable artifacts-- even in areas that were not in the selected region.

    c.pfaffenbichler
    Community Expert
    c.pfaffenbichlerCommunity Expert
    Community Expert
    August 16, 2024

    Keep in mind: 1024px x 1024px. 

    OMNiArt
    OMNiArt
    Participating Frequently
    May 31, 2024

    I agree. The Beta version was so much better. Generative fill is becoming useless to me. And now we have a generative credit cap started a couple weeks ago. Since that became a thing. I haven't produced one generative fill I could use. Wasted credits. Too bad, it was excellent last Fall.

    P
    Pawel287536848jwqAuthor
    Known Participant
    June 10, 2024
    It's not fair to charge for something that doesn't work properly. Wasting credits just because you hope that one time you will get the desired effect is nonsense. Additionally, Adobe spying on customers is total nonsense and disrespect for the customer!!
     
     
     
    c.pfaffenbichler
    Community Expert
    c.pfaffenbichlerCommunity Expert
    Community Expert
    June 10, 2024
    quote
    Additionally, Adobe spying on customers is total nonsense and disrespect for the customer!!

    Have you read this 

    https://blog.adobe.com/en/publish/2024/06/06/clarification-adobe-terms-of-use

    yet or do you rely on alarmist … on the web? 

      CMass
      Community Manager
      CMassCommunity Manager
      Community Manager
      December 13, 2023

      Thank you for the clarification. Moving to Photoshop Bugs

        P
        Pawel287536848jwqAuthor
        Known Participant
        December 13, 2023

        All the issues appear in main Photoshop not in a Beta version so im not sure why its moved to Photoshop Beta. Whoever use main version of Photoshop can have same issue.

         

          CMass
          Community Manager
          CMassCommunity Manager
          Community Manager
          December 11, 2023

          @Pawel287536848jwq  Thank you for reaching out and starting a discussion on the community. As a standard practice, we usually ask for visual examples of what you're encountering, such as screenshots, videos, or files. Thank you, @Monika Gause for requesting this. 

          I will share the image you provided with the team, but I need more context. 

          1. Was this done in Photoshop or Firefly? 
          2. What was your prompt? 
          3. What makes the results poor quality? 

           

          In Firefly we also have a mechanism to share feedback directly by clicking on the three dots of the generated image. 

            P
            Pawel287536848jwqAuthor
            Known Participant
            December 12, 2023

            Thank you for respond.

            1. It was done in Photoshop updated to latest version, 25.2

            2.My prompt was simple same as before. Just using quick selection tool of the area to be changed (suit ) and state " white suit, yellow suit"

            3. This question is a bit odd. Is like when you go to doctor and doctor asking you about case of your illnes.

            I got new 3 examples. Photo from Freepik website of man wear suit.

            Number 1 is a breaching most rules from Adobe !! Adobe implement guidelines for prompts and when my prompt was "white suit" i got this. In this case, Adobe is insulting me, so who is breaching guidelines !!!

            P
            Pawel287536848jwqAuthor
            Known Participant
            December 12, 2023

            Number 4 photo is quick try in Adobe firefly. Compared to the oryginall.

            Monika Gause
            Community Expert
            Monika GauseCommunity Expert
            Community Expert
            December 8, 2023

            Can you perhaps show examples of that?

              P
              Pawel287536848jwqAuthor
              Known Participant
              December 8, 2023

              Thanks for answer. Clearly you dont read properly posts if you cant see example already stated in my post. Clothes doesnt change (man with suit as a oryginal-try to change to white t-shirt) final photo guy with slighty different suit.

              Photo of branches try to add squirell , generative fill add bird without head. Photo of my son wearing cap,try to change cap to long hair example of this below. Honestly its too many examples to write here

                Monika Gause
                Community Expert
                Monika GauseCommunity Expert
                Community Expert
                December 8, 2023
                @Pawel287536848jwq  schrieb:

                Thanks for answer. Clearly you dont read properly posts if you cant see example already stated in my post.

                 

                Oh, thank you very much. This is a community forum with 95% of people being not even staff.

                 

                Examples about visual things need to be seen. 

                  Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
                  Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices