Generative Upscale Hallucinations: Do not use Adobe Firefly model

[Another_ACR_User]

Be careful: Generative Upscale does not do what the Adobe text describes, i.e., “create a new, larger document with more detail."

Today, I tried using it on a map (Using Photoshop 27.2.0, Tahoe 26.2), thinking that it would enlarge and sharpen the file. It did not. Instead, it made up false details throughout the map. For example, it created rivers where there were not rivers, and it gave mountains shapes that were not on the original map. If I hadn't taken a closer look at the map, it would have been a total disaster. 

Firefly is cearly not ready for commercial applications, and Adobe needs to better describe what it is doing with it.

[Sameer K]

Hey, @Another_ACR_User. Thanks for bringing the feedback. It'll help if you could include a sample file, and the output. 

I'll share this with the product team for review.

Sameer K
(Type '@' and type my name to mention me when you reply)

[Another_ACR_User]

Here are a few examples where can see rivers appearing, roads rerouting, and lakes turning into valleys.  

[Srishti Bali]

Hi @Another_ACR_User, 

Thank you for providing these screenshots. I will forward them to the Product team for their review. I will keep this thread updated as soon as we have any information.

Regards,

Srishti