Identify People Distractions in Images in LrC and PS

[westdr1dw]

An observation in removing people in images. 

I removed a few people from an image in LrC. I then decided another person should not be in the image. However, when I moved the image to PS and tried to remove them it failed to recognize the person.  Using the same image in PS I was able to add the person and remove them.

Are images tagged in the removal of people between apps?

Am I missing a step in transferring the image between LrC and PS?

[Conrad_C]

It’s known that Lightroom Classic is a parametric editor and Photoshop is primarily a pixel-based editor, so a feature of the same name might be implemented with different underlying code in each app. For example, you might have noticed that when people are detected in Lightroom Classic each detected person is marked as a discrete object so you can select one and exclude it from the deletion, but in Photoshop editing detected persons requires painting them out or in.

How are you sending the image to Photoshop after removing people in Lightroom Classic?

Are you…

A. Using the Lightroom Classic command Photo > Edit In > Adobe Photoshop

B .Using the Lightroom Classic command Photo > Edit In > Open as Smart Object in Photoshop

C. Another way (describe how)

When you use option A, people detected for removal aren’t remembered when an image is passed between Lightroom Classic and Photoshop because the original is rendered down to a single layer of just pixels, irreversibly applying any Lightroom Classic edits. Any future people removal in Photoshop must be done with the different pixel-based Photoshop option in the Remove tool, not the object-based way it was done in Lightroom Classic.

When you use option B, which preserves the raw data as a Smart Object in Photoshop, it’s possible to edit people the same way you did it in Lightroom Classic, but you have to start by double-clicking the Smart Object layer to open it in Adobe Camera Raw. In Camera Raw, select the Remove tool and expand People distraction removal and you will find that the edit pins are there in case you want to restore any removed people.

[westdr1dw]

Thanks, I will try as you suggest in removing from ACR. When transferring images between LrC and PS I use the Right Mouse key/Edit In Photoshop.

[westdr1dw]

A follow on to Conrad C

I went the long route Photo/Edit In and opened ACR using the Filter tab. I was able to remove a person in ACR which LrC did not detect. 

However, there was still an additional person I wanted to remove. With the image in PS I attempted to remove the individual without success. The image is complex where they are sitting behind a table with ojects in front.

In PS using select Object Selection/People, the person is not detected. 

Only trying to get a better understanding of the cause.

Thanks