Mac vs PC

[romany36267645]

Does anyone have any insight into how a top-end Apple system would compare to an equivalent PC system? For example a Mac Studio M2 Max with 96GB RAM vs i9 13900k, 4070ti, and 96GB RAM. 

The only benchmark I can find for Photoshop is PugetBench, but this seems to still have the Mac system running through Rosetta. In other relevant benchmarks (Single Core CPU) the PC seems to perform better, but I'm unsure of how this would translate to real-world Photoshop usage. Does Photoshops optimization for the Apple processors make up for its weaker raw computing power? 

Also, from an OS standpoint does either platform have a considerable advantage at the moment? In regards to reliability/stability, and color management. 

[D Fosse]

@Lumigraphics 

If you want a reliable workhorse that never gives any problems, ever, build your own Windows machine.

The problem isn't Windows or Mac. The problem is that off-the-shelf manufacturers tend to insert all kinds of "helpful" layers and interfaces between the hardware and operating system. It stands to reason that they will do anything they can to put their own stamp on the machine - they didn't build the hardware, they didn't make the OS. So they put stuff in there, modify GPU drivers, etc.

Easily 95% of all Windows problems here are with laptops. That's not to say you can't get a reliable laptop, but I would start with a thorough cleanup. Get rid of all the junk, strip it down as much as possible. If Windows is left to its own devices, it's extremely solid and reliable.

[Lumigraphics]

Most people don't have the skills or desire to build their own computer, and wouldn't know how to find compatible drivers or set up hardware options. Most people also don't have the skills or desire to de-crapify a new computer. On top of that, Windows is a pile of hot garbage.

I have the skill and knowledge to build my own computers and zero desire to do so.

As for laptops, I've owned numerous Mac laptops that have all worked great.

[Chrisatom]

We have custom-built PCs that on paper are fantastic but there are issues with them. When they work well, they're great but very few professionals will use off the shelf PCs. When it comes to After Effects specifically, it runs so much better on an Apple Silicon Mac than a powerful PC.

[Trevor.Dennis]

Workstation providers build to order with whatever spec you ask for.  I guess that is not exactly off-the-shelf, but it sure as heck isn't home built.   I have found that it cost exactly the same to get a made to order workstation as to buy all the parts and build it yourself, so why would you give yourself the hassle?

[D Fosse]

What hassle? Seriously? I enjoy it, it's great fun! A couple of hours of zen peace of mind.

I've no idea why so many say it's difficult.

[Lumigraphics]

Some people love gardening, too. Ugh. I have a brown thumb and no clue how anyone can stand digging in the dirt voluntarily. Just saying.

[Chrisatom]

I built one of the workstations (based off a spec from Pudget Systems) and really enjoyed it. It kind of feels like you'll argue with whatever I reply with. I like pineapple on pizza. How does that sit with you?

[Lumigraphics]

Pineapple and ham. Yum.