Skip to main content
AdobeAlexS
Inspiring
Oct 17, 2019 7:32 PM UTC
Answered

Missing some magic

Magic Extractor is documented thus:

 

Open the photo containing the object you want to extract.

To limit what appears in the Magic Extractor dialog box, make a preliminary selection using the Oval or Rectangular selection tool.
Choose Image > Magic Extractor.
The Magic Extractor dialog box opens with the Foreground Brush tool selected by default.

 

However after making my preliminary selection there is nothing on the menu (Image > Magic Extractor). Any ideas?

 

Using Photoshop Elements 2020 in Windows.

 

Thx

    This topic is closed to new replies. Start a new post to keep the conversation going.
    99jon
    99jonCorrect answer
    Legend
    Oct 17, 2019 8:27 PM UTC

    The Magic Extractor was removed several years ago. Photoshop Elements 2020 now has a new guided edit “Object removal” which uses content aware technology. See my blog YouTube video tutorial.

     

    View reply

    6 replies

    Fujifiend
    Participant
    Dec 22, 2022 5:21 PM UTC

    Sadly this is absolutely not the same thing. The magic extractor enabled very quick extraction of objects isolating them on a a transparent background, perfect for inserting into other photos, web sites, documents. It was brilliant, simple and very very quick. This video describes object removal, which is totally different. There appears to be no simple replacement for magic extractor, so I keep my old copy of Elements 10 on my machine just to be able to use this feature.

    Translate
      99jon
      99jon
      Legend
      Dec 23, 2022 8:39 AM UTC

      Adobe revamped the guided edit for background replacement in PSE 2023 and the select subject button is powered by A.I.

       

      For the background you can choose a solid color, an abstract preset, your own photo or none. Choosing none will give you a transparent background.

       

      See my updated YouTube video.

       

      The Background Eraser tool is also available to do the job manually. Choose the Eraser and select it from the tool options bar – see image below.

       

      Translate
      AdobeAlexSAuthor
      Inspiring
      Dec 23, 2022 12:56 PM UTC

      You had me excited for a little while however "select subject" etc appears not much different from the 2020 version. There appears to be no change in the algorithm other than it may run slightly faster. Usage appears almost identical.

      Translate
        AdobeAlexSAuthor
        Inspiring
        Oct 17, 2019 8:59 PM UTC

        Thanks for the info. Guess their documentation needs updating..

        Translate
        99jon
        99jonCorrect answer
        Legend
        Oct 17, 2019 8:27 PM UTC

        The Magic Extractor was removed several years ago. Photoshop Elements 2020 now has a new guided edit “Object removal” which uses content aware technology. See my blog YouTube video tutorial.

         

        Translate
          TerryBB
          Participant
          Aug 9, 2020 6:52 PM UTC

          Just saw this. Just updated from 9 to 2020. regretting it already.

          Magic extractor was so much easier to use to take a bit of image, with no backgrouind, to use elsewhere. Which is pretty fundamental.

          Translate
          Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
          Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices