Audio file sounds fine in media player, but when put into Premiere Pro it gets crackly.

Been looking all over the place for a fix for this but can't find anyone with the same problem as me. I recorded some audio with my friend for a Youtube video, and the audio file sounds PERFECTLY fine playing through the media player on my computer. However, when I put it into premiere pro, THEN it sounds really clicky and sort of cuts out a lot for his audio only.

We were recording through a dual XLR microphone setup using streamlabs OBS. We've done this a million other times and have never had the issue before. Recording in 48khz and the sequence setting in premeire is set to the same thing. Premiere pro doesn't detect it as variable frame rate either. I've tried setting my default input in audio hardware to "No Input" and setting the latency higher too, neither seemed to work.

I've tried every solution I've been able to find for similiar sounding issues but none of them fix the weird clicking noise. Exporting it also has the clicking noises too. Any solutions anyone might have would be much appreciated!

I attached two examples. The one with the black background is the audio as it sounds in premiere, it has the weird staticy/clicky noise. The one with the green background is the one playing out of the media player, it sounds normal.