Skip to main content
E
Eddie5F90
Participant
March 17, 2021
Question

Lossless audio codec

  • March 17, 2021
  • 2 replies
  • 7225 views

Which is the best codec for lossless audio in still image video? Apple ProRes, GoPro Cineform, or Avid DNxHD or is there other codec to use when exporting lossless audio in still image video? I want to make a still image video but with the lossless audio  

This topic has been closed for replies.

2 replies

Averdahl
Community Expert
AverdahlCommunity Expert
Community Expert
March 17, 2021

All codecs you mention are capable of exporting uncompressed audio. It all comes down to what you want to do with the final video. The problem is that many media players cannot playback the video, but you can use third party players such as PotPlayer or VLC. The resulting file will be huuuuge as well.

 

The best solution would be (?) H.264 with linear PCM audio. This cannot be achived with Premiere Pro´s native H.264 exporter but can be done in this third party plug-in: TMPGEnc Movie Plug-in AVC for Premiere Pro.

 

But without knowing what you want to do, iow do a Blu-ray or upload to YouTube/Vimeo or just watch it at home on a laptop it is hard to guide. What do you want to do with the file, whats the goal?

 

 

    E
    Eddie5F90Author
    Participant
    March 18, 2021

    I'm trying to upload the file to YouTube and Instagram. What I'm trying to do is to export the still image video and want to the sound to sound exactly like the soundtrack lossless. I don't know if you understand? Tell me what to do please?

    neil wilkes
    neil wilkes
    Legend
    March 19, 2021

    Sorry to say you cannot actually do this. No streaming site allows lossless audio, more is the pity.

    I also must disagree with the comment from Averdahl below, as once you teach yourself how to hear codec fluff, you cannot unhear it. YouTube & the like almost all use either AAC-LC at pitiful bitrates, and I know from YouTube that in 3/4 of the ccases you can hear a lot more than mere codec fluff - at a lot of channels the audio is so bad it is distorted, or bubbly or at times both.

    The best thing is to recall that the audio is half of the production and not an afterthought (as your post heavily implies already) and always use the highest quality setting for audio that you can. But getting your uploaded file to a streaming channel to sound exactly like the original is simply not going to happen. If you are serious about this subject, I can highly recommend the Sonnox Fraunhofer Pro-Codec application, which has a standalone component as well as a plugin component specifically to allow you to hear what your lossy encoded audio will sound like before you actually run the process - it encodes & decodes 'on the fly' for you and better yet you can set up comparisons with up to 4 different settings.

    I use this all the time, and it exists for both Mac & PC.

      P
      Community Expert
      Phillip HarveyCommunity Expert
      Community Expert
      March 17, 2021

      Straight out of Premiere you're going to have to choose a post-production codec like the ones that you've listed. I personally would use ProRes. You might find that the resulting file size on this is not going to be what you want, as it'll be quite large. It may be possible to mux together a compressed, long-GOP codec, like H264 with an uncompressed audio track in another software. Maybe Shutter Encoder? I haven't done that before, so hopefully someone else can chime in on that.

      Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
      Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices