Skip to main content
Participant
June 17, 2019
Question

Music Video Playlist For Wedding - Audio Issue

  • June 17, 2019
  • 5 replies
  • 318 views

Hi there,

I'm new to video editing and would be grateful for someone's advice on exporting audio.

My fiancee and I are creating a music video playlist for our wedding reception. I downloaded the music videos, deleted their sound file and replaced them with mp3 files assuming these were better quality. We exported the whole playlist as a H.264 file. When we played back the file through a TV, we noticed some songs sounded crisper, louder and with a clear beat whilst others sounded slightly muted in comparison.

I tried again only this time I exported the audio on its own as an uncompressed Waveform file. It still sounded like some songs were louder than others.

Some songs were ripped from CDs whilst others were downloaded from iTunes so I'm not if it's perhaps the original mp3 files themselves although they sound loud and clear when playing them on the laptop.

Has anyone had any experience exporting music video playlists and is there standard export for this? If not, would increasing the decibels on the lower sounding mp3 files help?

Many thanks in advance for your help.

Andrew

    This topic has been closed for replies.

    5 replies

    Legend
    June 17, 2019

    Legend
    June 17, 2019

    The alternative, as you've discovered, is to delete the sountracks from the videos, and find 'better' versions of the music, and that mean unlinking stuff, deleting, and then putting new stuff in ( hopefully wav files converted in audition from your new source) and then hope the length of music matches length of video ( unlikely, and you'd have to sync it ) and then you'd STILL have to adjust the volumes for each video to match each other … typically this is somewhere around -6db as the LOUDEST you ever want to get cause that's like REALLY LOUD.

    hehe..

    Participant
    June 17, 2019

    Many thanks again Rodneyb56060189!

    I think you've made me realise to leave it as it is! Haha. I've already exported all the music videos as 1 file (it's 35 GB!) so I might just leave it at that.

    The set up is we've hired a sound technician who will play the playlist from a laptop/hard drive which will be connected to two screens. I'm sure he'll be able to judge and control the volume levels when each song plays

    I think I just wanted peace of mind that all the songs we're the same quality and didn't sound too compressed. But as you've said it may become an arduous task on my part if I play each song as their sound levels.

    Thank you again!

    Legend
    June 17, 2019

    oh, P.S.   exporting h264 should be fine.

    Legend
    June 17, 2019

    I think at this point it's best to keep things sorta simple or it will get really time consuming for you and not very much fun.

    I'm gonna pick apart this statement...

    ============

    My fiancee and I are creating a music video playlist for our wedding reception. I downloaded the music videos, deleted their sound file and replaced them with mp3 files assuming these were better quality. We exported the whole playlist as a H.264 file. When we played back the file through a TV, we noticed some songs sounded crisper, louder and with a clear beat whilst others sounded slightly muted in comparison.

    ============

    when you say a music video playlist, what exactly do you mean ??  Are you making a BD or DVD which has a menu of all the videos to choose from on the TV ?  How is the playlist used by you and guests at reception ?

    Keep in mind, by the way, that people at the reception will be celebrating with you and wife and not really listening to the fine points of music 'fidelity' like a person at Avery Fischer Hall would be listening to a night of "Mozart".

    If each music choice on TV is via a memory stick then you are exporting each video as separate videos ??

    I, unfortunately, don't have the CC version (your version) of PPro, so I don't know if you can export a timeline making each clip a separate FILE when you export.  If using a memory stick in TV that's what I would do. Put the stuff into one timeline, and adjust the volume of each clip (video) to match the volumes, and just go with that.... otherwise you're looking at a ton of work and time and so on ???

    Legend
    June 17, 2019

    the only comparison I have is this:

    I bought music CD's, downloaded MP3 music from my library, and sometimes get free mp3 sound FX files from internet.  Except for the sound FX I put all the other stuff onto a memory stick (usb) that I use in my car.

    So, I have the stuff on my computer ( I usually play with a decent blue tooth speaker or my home stereo ( also using Bluetooth )...and on the memory stick copied from computer.

    At first I used audition to get the CD music, converted to wav, and adjusted volumes ( and sometimes bass / treble ) using the meters, so all of it would sound the same volume and bass, etc.  Then converted to mp3 for the final files for computer and car.

    After a while I found this to be too much work because EVERYTHING IS DIFFERENT and I got real tired of adjusting stuff etc. So now I just adjust the volume on the car radio to suit me.  Same on computer.  If you really want to make everything the same you have to go through the same stuff as I used to do.  Some of the mp3's you get will just sound bad no matter WHAT you do. Best to just toss them out and see if you can find a better version.

    Legend
    June 17, 2019

    P.S.

    everything you put into edit timeline should be wav files... no mp3's.   convert to wav 48khz and use them in editor...

    Participant
    June 17, 2019

    Hi Rodneyb56060189

    Thank you so much for your swift response!

    I actually got that wrong. They're M4A files, not MP3s, but that won't make a difference as you're right WAV files are better to use.

    If I converted my songs from M4A to WAV format in Premiere Pro will that make a difference do you think? The thing is once I do that, I have to import that audio file to match it with the the video and export it again... What's the best file type to export the final product without loss of quality?

    Many thanks