Numbers and punctuation jumping around in Premire Pro

So I've seen people attemp to describe similar problems, but it's also a bit difficult to describe, so let me be as clear as I can. 

I am using Premire Pro 22.1.2 on a Macbook. Using the text tool, I want to write

DECEMBER

25, 1971

However, when I go to write the second line, it glitches up like this:

 To be clear, I typed in "25, 1971" in that exact order, yet it appeared on the screen like you see above.

I can write other things with puncutation that doesn't misbehave, for example see:

But for some reason anything with numbers appears backwards. For example, here is what happens when I attempt to write 1, 2, 3, 4:

Here are my settings. Nothing looks weird to me here. Any ideas?