Skip to main content
MichaelStephens
Legend
December 15, 2016
Answered

Problems with masks, video transitions, and frame holds

  • December 15, 2016
  • 3 replies
  • 2919 views

I'm using PP CC 2017 and I'm running into two issues that I can't seem to resolve. I'm creating a video tutorial and I want to draw attention to a something in the software so I created a black color matte, placed it on video track 2, changed the opacity to 98%, added a mask to the color matte, positioned the mask to the area I want to draw attention, set the mask to invert, and added film dissolve transition on both sides of the matte so as the video plays the area outside the matte becomes dark.

The issue I'm seeing is that when I'm playing back the video the screen flashes white for one frame as soon as the timeline hits the color matte in the timeline. If I stop playing the video and backup to just before the matte then it doesn't flash. The same thing occurs when I'm just scrubbing the timeline and after the flash of white the matte doesn't do it anymore.

I wouldn't mind the flash except that it appears in the final render as well. I've found that the problem only occurs when I'm using a combination of a mask and a video transition. If I delete the mask or delete the transition, then the flash doesn't occur. If I remove the transition and keyframe the opacity so it's doing the same thing as the video transition, then the white flash doesn't appear.

Obviously I would prefer to just use video transitions than having to change the opacity key frames for each matte, but I can't come up with any reason as to why it's having this problem.

The second issue is somewhat related to the first. I have a few segments of the video I want to hold while the narration plays out. If I use a frame hold on the video so I'm holding on a single frame of the video while my narration continues to play and then I go back to the rest of the video, the frame hold segment works perfectly. However, if I place anything else on a track above the frame hold segment and apply a video transition to the end of it, the frame hold clip on the track below becomes black as soon as the ending transition is finished. If i delete whatever is on the upper track, then the frame hold goes back to normal.

As I was trying to figure out what was going on with the frame holds, I found that if I placed the frame hold clip on a track above an edit that's using a video transition, that the lower transition part of the video acts like it's above the frame hold track.

I've tried this on two different computers with different specs and the same problem occurs on both of them. My main computer is an i7-5820 3.30Ghz 6-core, 32G Ram and an Nvidia Titan GPU, so power shouldn't be a problem.

    This topic has been closed for replies.
    Correct answer excited_Genie16B8

    I remove the transition and keyframe the opacity so it's doing the same thing as the video transition, then the white flash doesn't appear.

    Go with that.  Make the effect a Preset for ease of use.

    3 replies

    Participant
    February 11, 2023

    This is still an issue in February of 2023. Adobe is so expensive and this is such a major waste of time. Do better Adobe.

    Participant
    August 21, 2023

    It's unbelievable that this is still an issue. Every year or so I spend hours searching for a fix/update. I have so many transitions I will have to manually keyframe on a current project and I'm over it. It can be tough to search for, but if you're tenacious, you'll find that there are so many posts about this issue on multiple websites. I've wasted so much time...

    Legend
    December 15, 2016

    For the Frame Hold, export out a PNG of that fame, and cut the clip to insert that image.

    excited_Genie16B8Correct answer
    Legend
    December 15, 2016

    I remove the transition and keyframe the opacity so it's doing the same thing as the video transition, then the white flash doesn't appear.

    Go with that.  Make the effect a Preset for ease of use.

    MichaelStephens
    Legend
    December 15, 2016

    Not ideal, but it will have to do until the bug gets fixed.

    I checked this out in Premiere Pro 2014 and it doesn't have any of these the problems.

    Legend
    December 15, 2016

    Be sure to let Adobe know about the issues.

    Feature Request/Bug Report Form