Skip to main content
Jeff Bugbee
Community Expert
Jeff BugbeeCommunity Expert
Community Expert
September 20, 2020
Answered

Scene Edit Detection not working

  • September 20, 2020
  • 17 replies
  • 26744 views

Anyone gotten Scene Edit Detection working? On my PC, I've tried a variety of media and scene edit detection simply does it's Analyzing, then nothing. No cuts, no edits.

 

On Windows 10, Premiere v14.4.0 (Build 38)

 

 

    Correct answer Jeff Bugbee

    I posted prematurely. I had installed the latest update and immediately ran Premiere and had edit detection fail. A simple reboot made the Scene Edit Detection work.

    17 replies

    Show previous replies
    H
    hidekifernando
    Participant
    April 27, 2023

    I've tried to use the scene edit detection tool several times in different ways, and it's still not working.

    Transcoded to Apple ProRes HQ a file that was 37GB turned into a 170GB file. Updated to the 22.6.4 Version of Premiere, updated the 23.3 version. Nesting, trying different files... Nothing.

     

    MacBook Pro M1 32GB RAM

    MacOS Ventura

    Premiere Pro 2023

      M
      Michael Grenadier
      Legend
      April 27, 2023

      do you want to send me a short clip and I'll see if I can get it to work?  I'm working on a new macstudio with premiere 23.2.  You can send me a direct message by clicking on my username at the top of my post.

      C
      cindyl29302053
      Participant
      March 12, 2023

      I have the same issue but on M2 pro Mac. 8 minute clip and the software makes no cuts although no error is displayed. 

      M
      Michael Grenadier
      Legend
      March 19, 2023

      What format are your sources?  An mpeg format is probably going to be problematic as each frame is not discreet.  Try transcoding to an all iframe format (also known as a mezzanine format) like prores and then try running scene edit detection.

      J
      JoshCee27
      Participant
      March 20, 2023

      Tried that and still no luck..

      EsTaF
      EsTaF
      Inspiring
      February 7, 2023

      2023. The problem is still there)))

      OldDesertLizard
      OldDesertLizard
      Known Participant
      February 21, 2023

      Every time I run it I get this:

      Retried, including the audio clip - same issue.

      M
      Michael Grenadier
      Legend
      February 21, 2023

      for the last 2 posters, please tell us your system specs: OS version, Premiere version, amount of RAM, Hardware specs including graphics card and your source properties and sequence settings...  

      م
      محمد علی25642169d145
      Participant
      August 14, 2022

      I also had this problem.
      It didn't work when the clip was without sound, but it worked when I imported the same clip with sound.

        L
        Lina5DDE
        Participant
        February 25, 2024

        You are the GOAT thank you!

        A
        alejandro72648186
        Participant
        July 12, 2022

        Happened to me. Found it didn't return any edits if it was a video WITHOUT AUDIO and audio track was selected. When I de-selected it, it worked. Seems like a bug.

          M
          marcob40653868
          Participating Frequently
          November 30, 2020

          Hi, I have premiere pro version 14.6.0 (build 51) windows 10, Scene Edit Detection is not working and there are no update available, is there a way of making it work?
          Thanks

            lamrasi5CED
            lamrasi5CED
            Participant
            June 22, 2021

            Same problem HABIBI

            Jeff Bugbee
            Community Expert
            Jeff BugbeeCommunity ExpertAuthorCorrect answer
            Community Expert
            September 20, 2020

            I posted prematurely. I had installed the latest update and immediately ran Premiere and had edit detection fail. A simple reboot made the Scene Edit Detection work.

              J
              jeff_b1
              Participant
              October 8, 2020

               .

              Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
              Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices