Skip to main content
joew71899760
Inspiring
September 24, 2017
Answered

Video artifacts after rendering - AMD video cards - how to avoid?

  • September 24, 2017
  • 2 replies
  • 3773 views

I'm getting random video artifacts when I render in my timeline.  Having read through many discussion threads on this topic, I believe this may be related to the hardware I'm running.

I'm running a Late-2013 MacPro 3 GHz 8-core with 64 GB RAM and AMD FirePro D700 video cards which have 6 GB RAM.

Software: I'm running Mac OS X Sierra 10.12.6 and Premiere 11.1.2 (22 Build.)

My footage is 2k (2048 x 1080) ProRes 422 and the timeline is a 1920 x 1080 with ProRes 422 preview files.

As an example, on the clip seen in screenshot (magnified a bit) I applied two Lumetri Color effects (one for the overall correction, plus a secondary CC for the interviewee's face.  Two effects because I cropped the secondary - you can't see it in my screen grab, but the interview subject is seen on frame left and he gets a different correction.)

I'm getting periodic, and random artifacts like this.

I re-rendered this section in Mercury Playback Engine Software Only mode - and it came out clean.

Am I doomed to super-slow renders?  Do AMD Video Cards still not work well with Premiere?  Or is there a workaround?

I haven't had time to test whether other video editing apps like Final Cut X would experience similar problems.

I have had the video card AND the motherboard replaced on my computer, recently, by Apple, after experiencing a lot of problems with video card-assisted rendering earlier this year.

Another observation - although my video won't play back smoothly in real time once the Lumetri effects are applied - if I do play it back with the assistance of the AMD video cards - I do see these artifacts during playback.  Not consistently on particular frames, they occur seemingly at random.  If I turn off the cards - playback w/ Mercury Playback Engine Software Only - I do not see the artifacts (I also get much choppier playback, as you'd expect.)

I look forward to everyone's thoughts on this.

This topic has been closed for replies.
Correct answer joew71899760

Update:  I had been rendering using Metal for my GPU acceleration.  I'm trying out OpenCL on clips which display the kind of render artifacts shown above.  I've had some success with this.  Maybe OpenCL is better supported than Metal?

2 replies

joew71899760
Inspiring
September 25, 2017

Sadly, for the Late-2013 Mac Pro, NVIDIA cards are not an option.... sigh.

R Neil Haugen
Legend
September 25, 2017

Can you use the newer AMD cards? There is some good performance there been reported  ...

Neil

Everyone's mileage always varies ...
joew71899760
joew71899760AuthorCorrect answer
Inspiring
September 24, 2017

Update:  I had been rendering using Metal for my GPU acceleration.  I'm trying out OpenCL on clips which display the kind of render artifacts shown above.  I've had some success with this.  Maybe OpenCL is better supported than Metal?

R Neil Haugen
Legend
September 24, 2017

And/or vice versa at times it seems.

I can only add the twin D700 systems have had a ton of problems, partly because of the cards overheating, and partly because of the modifications Apple makes to the first card if I recall correctly. Apple has replaced many of them ... for some users, 2-3 times before getting a pair that mostly sort of worked.

Neil

Everyone's mileage always varies ...