Skip to main content
Enlightened_magnetism0D44
Enlightened_magnetism0D44
Participating Frequently
November 18, 2022
Answered

First post here, Hello! Image rejection, advice needed!

  • November 18, 2022
  • 5 replies
  • 1782 views

Whilst I appreciate that the image has been taken in heavy snowfall (the effect is intentional) and the subject is still clearly seen.  In my mind, this is a great image and actually one that I'm very proud of and even one that could have done reasonably well as it's so different to the other images taken in the same area.  Maybe it's just not meant for Stock photography purposes? Maybe I've just got sentimental about it.  Thanks all!

 

This topic has been closed for replies.
Correct answer Jill_C

It is a lovely scene, however when I zoom in I see a significant amount of noise. It might not be possible to reduce the noise without causing the image to be too soft.

5 replies

jacquelingphoto2017
jacquelingphoto2017
Community Expert
November 19, 2022

Hi @Enlightened_magnetism0D44 

The photo is underexposed and with chromatic noise.

You need to zoom in to between 100 and 200% to look for issues. To learn how to identify these issues, go through the information at this link.

Best wishes

Jacquelin

 

    J
    John PDX
    Inspiring
    November 18, 2022

    I think this is a fantastic photo.  What a great scene.  
    If we are going to post our versions of the photo I want in on the action.  I can't help myself, I love editing photos.

      Enlightened_magnetism0D44
      Enlightened_magnetism0D44Author
      Participating Frequently
      November 18, 2022

      Excellent! I think I may have to join the discord and share the raw file and see what people come up with, it's lovely seeing what people can do with their own take on each other's photos!

        Jill_C
        Jill_CCorrect answer
        Community Expert
        November 18, 2022

        It is a lovely scene, however when I zoom in I see a significant amount of noise. It might not be possible to reduce the noise without causing the image to be too soft.

        Jill C., Forum Volunteer
          Enlightened_magnetism0D44
          Enlightened_magnetism0D44Author
          Participating Frequently
          November 18, 2022

          You are correct, but that's for the most part caused by the thousands of snowflakes falling from the sky, so unfortunately it's real world noise, rather than camera/editing induced 🙂

          Jill_C
          Jill_C
          Community Expert
          November 18, 2022

          I don't think so. If you zoom in you see very noticeable color noise. What is the ISO?

          Jill C., Forum Volunteer
            RALPH_L
            RALPH_L
            Community Expert
            November 18, 2022

            I agree with @Ricky336 , 

            it is too dark, too green/blue, needs some sharpening, the tonal range needs to be corrected, blacks, shadow, midtones, highlights and whites. I would also crop down some to reduce the empty space and emphasize the subject.

            ========================================Photography is more than just pressing a button!========================================
              Enlightened_magnetism0D44
              Enlightened_magnetism0D44Author
              Participating Frequently
              November 18, 2022

              Thanks Ralph, I appreciate your input.  You may well be correct for Stock purposes, I do however feel that in terms of overall image it loses a great deal with such a crop. Maybe it's my screen but it also now looks over-sharpened - I appreciate you're just working with the Jpeg too though!

               

              Many thanks 🙂

                Enlightened_magnetism0D44
                Enlightened_magnetism0D44Author
                Participating Frequently
                November 18, 2022

                Saying that, your crop would make a lovely Christmas card too!

                Ricky336
                Ricky336
                Community Expert
                November 18, 2022

                Hello,

                Well, it depends on which side of the fence you are on.

                On the one hand, it could be said that the photo is dark and gloomy. You don't have a lot of mid-tones. You could increase the whites and blacks a bit.

                Another point is the white balance. In my view, it is rather green.

                On the other hand, it depends on what effect you want - dark and gloomy?

                For stock purposes, though, I don't think this is usable in its current state. You will need to make a few corrections.

                Exposure, white balance, black and white points, etc. 

                As a quick example:

                 

                  Enlightened_magnetism0D44
                  Enlightened_magnetism0D44Author
                  Participating Frequently
                  November 18, 2022

                  I actually think that's closer to what was rejected.  The only copy I could find was an older version on my phone.  The whites are def brighter.  I think the attached is what was uploaded.  Will get to my laptop later...

                  Enlightened_magnetism0D44
                  Enlightened_magnetism0D44Author
                  Participating Frequently
                  November 18, 2022

                  Oddly, the image that you posted appears greener than mine on my calibrated display (on my desktop at the moment).  

                  Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
                  Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices