Skip to main content
Participating Frequently
March 26, 2025
Question

Image Critique

  • March 26, 2025
  • 5 replies
  • 309 views

Hello, can someone tell me what is wrong with these images? I created them with AI and then removed the background so that I can upload them as png. I uploaded a bunch of similar images and looked for mistakes in the image, but all of them got rejected.

5 replies

Jill_C
Community Expert
Community Expert
March 26, 2025

The shadows on the chocolate cake plate don't make sense.

Jill C., Forum Volunteer
Participating Frequently
March 27, 2025

Hello, thank you for your response. I just wanted to ask because I don't quite see it. Light is coming from the top right, shadows are being cast towards the left. Did you mean that the reflection of the cake on the plate don't make sense?

A bit confused here.

daniellei4510
Community Expert
Community Expert
March 26, 2025

The chocolate cake: not sure why the plate is two-toned. Probably the AI trying to figure out where the shadow needs to be but miscalculated.

Adobe Community Expert | If you can't fix it, hide it; if you can't hide it, delete it.
Participating Frequently
March 27, 2025

I wanted a pastel pink colored plate, the ai mixed it up with white I suppose. Would you say the reflection of the cake on the plate don't make sense? Asking so that I can avoid stuff like this in the future.

Abambo
Community Expert
Community Expert
March 26, 2025

Even on the small previews, I see cutout issues.

ABAMBO | Hard- and Software Engineer | Photographer
Participating Frequently
March 27, 2025

Thanks for the response, I see the issue.

daniellei4510
Community Expert
Community Expert
March 26, 2025

The plate is not perfectly rounded in shape and some of the edges are wobbly.

 

Adobe Community Expert | If you can't fix it, hide it; if you can't hide it, delete it.
Participating Frequently
March 27, 2025

Edges are wobbly, yes. Any comments on the waffle image?

Participating Frequently
March 27, 2025

plate is also not rounded, I see it.

yamato713108855
Community Expert
Community Expert
March 26, 2025

Is it the same size as the one you posted?
The outline is spotty and uneven.
It would be better if you cut it out a little neater.

Participating Frequently
March 27, 2025

I think that might be the issue, thanks for your reply.

 

Participating Frequently
March 27, 2025

And also, I see now that this is a smaller version, my bad for not posting the original resolution here.