More Rejcted Images

Question

HiThis appears to be a common subject !!I am not a prolific submitter of images but until a few months back I would rarely have an image rejected for technical reasons ehch are so vague as to be useless.I shoot in raw and use the adobe editor to convert to jpg. I occasionally boost the saturation a little and modify exposure levels. I have got into the habit of sharpening a tad and some noise reduction if over 400 ISO. The first image image below was rejected and the second accepted afer I reconverted and did not sharpen or perform noise reduction. Could the 3rd image have been rejected as it is deemed to breach copyright ?Unfortunately I appear to be unable to be unable to attach any images as I exceed the limit.  The files are 14mb each. So should I resave them at smaller sizes ? Help

Abambo · Accepted Answer

No, I submitted the same image but without any noise reduction or sharpening. I have had a lot of images rejected recenly which appear to be since I I started using a different option in the Imagenomic noise reduction. The second image was the same photo but with no noise reduction. I have resubmitted other images having removed noise reduction which have subsequently been accepted. It just seems a bit mad - maybe it is just that different Abode quality checkers look at images difeerently somehow.

Check your assets at 100% and you will see the difference.

Left is the rejected, right is the accepted image. You see immediately a huge difference in the image quality.

As a side note: Both images should have been rejected because they expose huge compression artefacts. But the right image is also cutting down the image dynamic.

Abambo · Answer

There is no image attached here. Use the drag and drop area and upload one image.

Quality issues is about errors in the image file.

IP issues are a separate refusal. Assets may have multiple issues, the first one detected triggers the refusal.

Shooting bad pictures in raw still means that the pictures are bad. Shooting in raw only allows for a wider range of editing. That does not mean that the asset is of good quality. ISO 400 and above normally needs some consequential noise reduction processing.

Sign up

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Sign in to Adobe Community

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Scanning file for viruses.

This file cannot be downloaded