Skip to main content
Ar2rM
Known Participant
May 25, 2023
Resuelto

pictures of machines in motion

  • May 25, 2023
  • 3 respuestas
  • 2883 visualizaciones

Hi

I would like to ask you about my drone pictures.

I like to take pictures of slow going farm or bulding machines and even have sold one here.

The problem is that Adobe dosn't want to accept it. 

 

And my secound question: Why all of my photos of tractors or planes has been rejected? Reason was : copyright. Is there any way to sell photos of any machines?

Este tema ha sido cerrado para respuestas.
Mejor respuesta de Test Screen Name

You CANNOT sell photos of copyright items and trademarks. 

Imagine: you sell a picture of the John Deere tractor through Adobe Stock.

It is used to advertise a rival tractor (which says how much better it is than the John Deere).

John Deere sue the rival tractor company for breach of copyright and abuse of trademark.

But Adobe Stock promised all rights, so the rival tractor company sue Adobe Stock.

And YOU promised all rights, so Adobe Stock sue YOU. This could cost unlimited sums of money.

So Adobe is protecting you. You cannot use other people's copyright in your work, just as you would not want them to use YOUR copyright images in their work.

Some of these machines could be made "anonymous" by removing labels, but in some cases the very colours are trademarked.

This is of course a serious limitation on what you can photograph. People who photograph street scenes find the same problem, because everything is copyright: shop signs, coffee brands, cars, people's trainers (yes, really).

3 respuestas

Abambo
Community Expert
Community Expert
May 28, 2023

In addition to IP problems, your assets also have quality issues. So even without logos, they would probably not pass.

ABAMBO | Hard- and Software Engineer | Photographer
Ar2rM
Ar2rMAutor
Known Participant
May 29, 2023

Does reupload of rejected (by Adobe) photos is allowed? Now I have got more knowledge about required quality and I have the same question but in two versions:

 

- can I try develope the rejected photo one more time and try add it again or this is forbidden and they will ban me?

- can I replace a picture that has been accepted by Adobe? I know that I can try add this photo again (but better version) but I affrade that the message will be " You already have a lot ot this kind of photos".

Jill_C
Community Expert
Community Expert
May 29, 2023

Yes, you can upload a re-edited version of a previously rejected image and this will not get you banned; however continuing to make multiple attempts to do so might be flagged as spamming. I've submitted Re-edited images successfully, but if they're rejected after the second attempt, I don't spend any more time on that image. 

You can't "replace" an image, but you can delete a previously accepted image. After it's deleted, you can upload another one. By why would you want to delete an accepted image?

Jill C., Forum Volunteer
Jill_C
Community Expert
Community Expert
May 25, 2023

Read all of Adobe's guidelines on copyright, trademarks, privacy rights starting here:

https://helpx.adobe.com/stock/contributor/help/terminology-and-importance-of-copyright.html

Jill C., Forum Volunteer
Legend
May 25, 2023

You CANNOT sell photos of copyright items and trademarks. 

Imagine: you sell a picture of the John Deere tractor through Adobe Stock.

It is used to advertise a rival tractor (which says how much better it is than the John Deere).

John Deere sue the rival tractor company for breach of copyright and abuse of trademark.

But Adobe Stock promised all rights, so the rival tractor company sue Adobe Stock.

And YOU promised all rights, so Adobe Stock sue YOU. This could cost unlimited sums of money.

So Adobe is protecting you. You cannot use other people's copyright in your work, just as you would not want them to use YOUR copyright images in their work.

Some of these machines could be made "anonymous" by removing labels, but in some cases the very colours are trademarked.

This is of course a serious limitation on what you can photograph. People who photograph street scenes find the same problem, because everything is copyright: shop signs, coffee brands, cars, people's trainers (yes, really).

Ar2rM
Ar2rMAutor
Known Participant
May 25, 2023
 
quote

It is used to advertise a rival tractor (which says how much better it is than the John Deere).

John Deere sue the rival tractor company for breach of copyright and abuse of trademark.

 

OK- I fully understand what is trademark and in this case I should remove it from my picture and tags.

But rest of this picture is part of landscape. I didn't take this photo inside John Deer's factory. If competitors of JD wants to use this photos to show that ther produckt is better so what? As long as I didn't manipulate this picture it is like it is.

If I take photo of jet plane I don't reveal anythink that woul be secret. Everybothy (that is staing next to me) can see the same.

For example this photo:

Who can recognise what kind of jet plane is it?

h2obeek
Known Participant
May 28, 2023
quote

Composition has a set of guidelines it is also very subjective as to who is viewing it. Specs for what the image will be used for is vast from papers to web and more. In the end it is the buyer eyes and needs. Images can always be adjusted and crop by user.


By @h2obeek

The guidelines on composition are based on how the human brain looks at a picture. It's not that subjective, and viewing is astonishingly the same, even if the viewer is from a different culture. The buyer, if they can choose, will choose mostly the well framed picture. 


Yes true...but in my many years with clients is subject to the client as they were paying the bill.